FunkFreak75
Exit founder and leader Al Kooper (turning toward the production and A&R side of Columbia Records), here today is power vocalist David Clayton-Thomas. Other members remaining from the debut album include the excellent rhythm corps of bassist Jim Fielder, drummer Bobby Colomby, and guitarist Steve Katz as well as sax player Fred Lipsius and trombonist Dick Halligan (who now has added piano, flute, and organ to his The album was recorded in New York City at Columbia's 30th Street Studios ("The Church") during the span of October 7-22, 1968 and then released at the end of the year from where it dominated the charts, holding the #1 spot for six weeks in 1969, spawning three hit singles to each reach #2: "You've Made Me So Very Happy," "Spinning Wheel," and "And When I Die" before winning the 1970 Grammy Award for Album of the Year.
1. "Variations On A Theme By Erik Satie (1st and 2nd Movements)" * (2:30) performed rather faithfully by Steve Katz providing the chords normally left to the piano's left hand on his classical guitar with flutes, and/or recorders tracking the main melody up top--until, that is, until the tinkling of a percussionists winde chimes signals a bridge to a fully meted out Brass Rock version (the "2nd Movement") varying the notes and chords with highly-treated (flanged) drums, bass, and loud horn section. Interesting! (9.125/10)
2. "Smiling Phases" (5:10) a song that really puts on full display the band's power and enthusiastic energy while also introducing their powerful new vocalist, David Clayton-Thomas. After 90 seconds, the band launches into an impressive jazzy instrumental section in which bass player Jim Fielder, drummer Bobby Colomby show their skills as the horns and Fred Lipsius' piano show off their skills over what turns out to be a two-part movement: the first fast, the second slow and protracted, before returning to the opening motif for David and the band to finish with the same energy as they opened with to bookend the song. Nice! (9/10)
3. "Sometimes In Winter "(3:08) smooth, beautiful, fully-orchestrated music with the smooth vocal of Steve Katz, the band finds themselves creating more of that Jimmy Webb folkie, anachronistic Baroque Pop that is so pleasing to the ear. I like this song very much. Steve Katz could definitely have had a career as a singer: he sounds like a cross between a certain member of The Association and Bobby Darren. (9.25/10)
4. "More and More" (3:04) picking up where "Smiling Phases" left off (though David's voice is mixed a little more deeply into the soundscape than before). More creative uses for the horn section to inject their accents into the mix (substituting for the B.B. King-like blues guitar riffs). Jim and Bobby bring it with such amazing energy and skill! The futuristic (Frippian) guitar tone used by Steve Katz in the solo toward the end of the second minute, during the organ- based instrumental mid-section, is quite cool (and loud)! Incredibly tight and powerful musicianship on this complex tune. (9.125/10)
5. "And When I Die" (4:05) the hit cover of Laura Nyro's song, the song is notable for its dynamic shift between its sparse, dirge-like harmonica opening, the ensuing easy-going circus-music-like verses and the way the music turns to vaudeville-Western-showtune-like as they go on. And then there are the dramatically-held suspension of the song's title in the chorus and unusual pauses. Very much like something one would see on a Broadway musical. The faithful rendering of a rather complicated composition is the most impressive part for me (on a song that I've never really been very high on). (9/10)
6. "God Bless The Child" (5:56) another song that feels stage-worthy (which makes sense since it was composed by Arthur Herzog, Jr. and Billie Holiday). In a very interesting (and totally unexpected) twist, at 3:06 the song turns into a Afro-Cubano-flavored piano- and percussion-based jam for the horn players to really stretch out: both collectively and each, individually. But then at 4:24 the song comes back to its origins (though with noticeably more forceful horns, more organ, and the joinder of a bluesy harmonica, which weren't so prevalent in the opening). Ballsy but these guys are definitely up to the challenge. (9.125/10)
7. "Spinning Wheel" (4:07) one of those memorable brainworm songs, this one composed by newcomer David Clayton- Thomas. The horns were always my favorite part though David is solid (and even able to show some sensitivity). Definitely the most interchangeable song with the other Brass Rock pioneer, CHICAGO (Transit Authority). The instrumental section in the middle (which is sometimes cut out for radio play) is pretty cool--as is the finale with it's horn blasts, great drumming, and calliope-like recorder play. (9/10)
8. "You've Made Me So Very Happy" (4:19) the album's first single release, it was borrowed from the Motown catalogue having been covered by one of its authors, Brenda Holloway in a mildly-successful 1967 release as a 45 rpm single (the final arrangement of which Ms. Holloway fought hard to control, a battle she ultimately lost--which led to her leaving Motown/Tamla). BS&T's version was a massive chart topper that remains memorable and emotionally relevant to this day. I am most impressed by David Clayton-Thomas' ability to tone it down and soften his delivery for the tender, sensitive verses. (9.25/10)
9. "Blues-Part II" (11:45) an instrumental epic that opens with organ, bass, drums, all of which are quite simple and rudimentary (which is greatly disappointing considering the absolutely jaw-dropping skills the band's rhythm section has shown in the super-tight, super demanding arrangements of all their vocal songs). By the time the fifth minute rolls around the band has finally settled into something more meaty (though, ironically, it's a two-chord vamp) over which Fred Lipsius performs a long multi-part solo on his alto sax: at first over the fast-tempo vamp but then equally- impactful over the slowed down for the seventh and eighth minutes. How humorous is it that the band (Jim Fielder) chooses the "Sunshine of Your Love"/"In-a-gadda-da-vida" bass line to open and carry the next section. Luckily, he lets go of it at 8:40, whereupon the band transitions into a purely-Blues motif over which David sings in a genuinely-feeling blues tradition as Steve Katz tries to project a Blues guitar tone and style while Bobby bashes away on the drum kit beneath and the horn section slowly ramps up their intensity--until someone in the production booth decided to pull the plug: they slowly fade the song out even while David is launching into a classic Wilson Pickett lyric with increasing power and emotion! (22/25)
10. "Variations On A Theme By Erik Satie (1st Movement)" * (1:37) a replication of the opening movement from the beginning of the album, this time ending before the Brass Rock rendering starts--with the sound of a door slamming shut! (4.75/5)
* Adapted from Satie's "Trois Gymnopédies"
Total time 45:41
A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of genre-leading Brass Rock. Though I am nowhere near as much a fan of this album as their debut, I recognize the superior craftsmanship that went into the rendering of each and every song and cannot imagine denying it it's deserved masterpiece status.