JAN GARBAREK

Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion / World Fusion / Avant-Garde Jazz / Third Stream / Post Bop / Classic Fusion • Norway
Jazz music community with discographies, reviews and forums
JAN GARBAREK picture
Saxophonist whose icy, contemplative style epitomizes ECM Records' high-quality improvisational art music.

Norwegian saxophonist Jan Garbarek's icy tone and liberal use of space and long tones has long been perfect for the ECM sound and, as a result, he is on many recordings for that label, both as a leader and as a sideman. He had won a competition for amateur jazz players back in 1962, leading to his first gigs. Garbarek worked steadily in Norway throughout the remainder of the '60s, usually as a leader but also for four years with George Russell (who was in Scandinavia for a long stretch). Garbarek began recording for ECM in the early '70s and, although he had opportunities to play with Chick Corea and Don Cherry, his association with Keith Jarrett's European quartet in the mid-'70s made him famous, resulting in the classic recordings My Song and Belonging. In the '80s, Garbarek's
read more...
Thanks to silent way for the addition and snobb for the updates

Buy JAN GARBAREK music

JAN GARBAREK Online Videos

See all JAN GARBAREK videos

JAN GARBAREK Discography

JAN GARBAREK albums / top albums

JAN GARBAREK George Russell Presents Esoteric Circle album cover 4.02 | 5 ratings
George Russell Presents Esoteric Circle
Avant-Garde Jazz 1970
JAN GARBAREK Afric Pepperbird album cover 3.90 | 16 ratings
Afric Pepperbird
Avant-Garde Jazz 1970
JAN GARBAREK SART (with Bobo Stenson / Terje Rypdal / Arild Andersen / Jon Christensen) album cover 3.41 | 12 ratings
SART (with Bobo Stenson / Terje Rypdal / Arild Andersen / Jon Christensen)
Avant-Garde Jazz 1971
JAN GARBAREK Triptykon (with Arild Andersen & Edward Vesala) album cover 3.93 | 8 ratings
Triptykon (with Arild Andersen & Edward Vesala)
Avant-Garde Jazz 1973
JAN GARBAREK Witchi-Tai-To album cover 3.75 | 13 ratings
Witchi-Tai-To
Post Bop 1974
JAN GARBAREK Dansere album cover 3.24 | 8 ratings
Dansere
Post Bop 1976
JAN GARBAREK Dis album cover 3.68 | 8 ratings
Dis
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 1977
JAN GARBAREK Places album cover 4.43 | 10 ratings
Places
Classic Fusion 1978
JAN GARBAREK Photo With Blue Sky, White Cloud, Wires, Windows And A Red Roof album cover 3.80 | 10 ratings
Photo With Blue Sky, White Cloud, Wires, Windows And A Red Roof
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 1979
JAN GARBAREK Jan Garbarek, Kjell Johnsen : Aftenland album cover 3.08 | 4 ratings
Jan Garbarek, Kjell Johnsen : Aftenland
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 1980
JAN GARBAREK Eventyr album cover 4.48 | 8 ratings
Eventyr
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 1981
JAN GARBAREK Paths, Prints album cover 3.90 | 8 ratings
Paths, Prints
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 1982
JAN GARBAREK Wayfarer album cover 4.00 | 5 ratings
Wayfarer
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 1983
JAN GARBAREK It's OK To Listen To The Grey Voice album cover 4.45 | 12 ratings
It's OK To Listen To The Grey Voice
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 1985
JAN GARBAREK All Those Born With Wings album cover 4.43 | 5 ratings
All Those Born With Wings
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 1987
JAN GARBAREK Legend of the Seven Dreams album cover 4.20 | 6 ratings
Legend of the Seven Dreams
World Fusion 1988
JAN GARBAREK I Took Up the Runes album cover 3.65 | 8 ratings
I Took Up the Runes
World Fusion 1990
JAN GARBAREK Star (with Miroslav Vitous, Peter Erskine) album cover 3.91 | 8 ratings
Star (with Miroslav Vitous, Peter Erskine)
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 1991
JAN GARBAREK Ragas And Sagas (Ustad Fateh Ali Khan & Musicians From Pakistan) album cover 3.92 | 8 ratings
Ragas And Sagas (Ustad Fateh Ali Khan & Musicians From Pakistan)
World Fusion 1992
JAN GARBAREK Twelve Moons album cover 3.31 | 12 ratings
Twelve Moons
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 1993
JAN GARBAREK Officium (with The Hilliard Ensemble) album cover 3.71 | 8 ratings
Officium (with The Hilliard Ensemble)
Third Stream 1994
JAN GARBAREK Madar (with Anouar Brahem - Ustad Shaukat Hussain) album cover 4.26 | 8 ratings
Madar (with Anouar Brahem - Ustad Shaukat Hussain)
World Fusion 1994
JAN GARBAREK Visible World album cover 3.83 | 10 ratings
Visible World
World Fusion 1996
JAN GARBAREK Rites album cover 4.38 | 11 ratings
Rites
World Fusion 1998
JAN GARBAREK Mnemosyne (with The Hilliard Ensemble) album cover 3.83 | 6 ratings
Mnemosyne (with The Hilliard Ensemble)
Third Stream 1999
JAN GARBAREK In Praise of Dreams album cover 3.83 | 9 ratings
In Praise of Dreams
World Fusion 2004
JAN GARBAREK Officium Novum (with The Hilliard Ensemble) album cover 4.03 | 6 ratings
Officium Novum (with The Hilliard Ensemble)
Third Stream 2010

JAN GARBAREK EPs & splits

JAN GARBAREK live albums

JAN GARBAREK Til Vigdis album cover 3.50 | 1 ratings
Til Vigdis
Avant-Garde Jazz 1967
JAN GARBAREK Dresden: In Concert album cover 4.04 | 5 ratings
Dresden: In Concert
World Fusion 2009
JAN GARBAREK Magico: Carta de Amor (with Egberto Gismonti/Charlie Haden) album cover 2.50 | 2 ratings
Magico: Carta de Amor (with Egberto Gismonti/Charlie Haden)
World Fusion 2012
JAN GARBAREK Jan Garbarek and The Hillard Ensemble : Remember me, my dear album cover 3.50 | 1 ratings
Jan Garbarek and The Hillard Ensemble : Remember me, my dear
Third Stream 2019

JAN GARBAREK demos, promos, fans club and other releases (no bootlegs)

JAN GARBAREK re-issues & compilations

JAN GARBAREK Works album cover 4.00 | 1 ratings
Works
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 1984
JAN GARBAREK Selected Recordings - Rarum II album cover 3.50 | 1 ratings
Selected Recordings - Rarum II
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 2002
JAN GARBAREK Dansere (Compilation) album cover 5.00 | 1 ratings
Dansere (Compilation)
Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion 2012

JAN GARBAREK singles (0)

JAN GARBAREK movies (DVD, Blu-Ray or VHS)

JAN GARBAREK Reviews

JAN GARBAREK SART (with Bobo Stenson / Terje Rypdal / Arild Andersen / Jon Christensen)

Album · 1971 · Avant-Garde Jazz
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
FunkFreak75
The album was recorded on April 14–15, 1971, at Arne Bendiksen Studio in Oslo, Norway, and then released by ECM Records in November of 1971.

1. "Sart" (14:54) acoustic space with the occasional instrumental note, riff, or flourish to come close to that which normal mortals would consider "music," this display feels more like a hiker's search for water while crossing the Sonoran Desert. I am not one of those listeners who find beauty, meaning, much less redemption in this kind of pretentious music. Even in the 12th minute when the musicians finally start to "come together" it only sounds like grating and scratching. (24/30)

2. "Fountain of Tears - Part I and II" (6:02) more creative noise-making from each of the musicians on their respective instruments (or not: they could have just done a Talking Heads switcheroo where each takes one of the others' instruments to see what sounds/music they can make on them). Wow is this bad! I mean it does take a little talent to make this cacophony together with others but, really: why? Even the gentle pastoral flute, electric piano musings, and bowed bass weave in the final 90 seconds fails to merge into what I would call "music." (7.5/10)

3. "Song of Space" (9:38) A continuation of the previous song with Bobo Stenson taking on the flute's role with his piano? Why must music go in this amelodic, astructured, anarchistic direction? Is it a reflection of nihilism, deconstruction, and/or randomization or just a need to feel power through rebelliousness? It just feels violent to me. (17.25/20)

4. "Close Enough for Jazz" (1:57) Arild Anderson's lone compositional contribution to the album actual uses a near-normal weave of near-normal sax and bowed-bass to express its ideas! Praise the Buddha! (4.375/5)

5. "Irr" (7:14) fancy double bass playing opens this one, Arild playing tout seul before Jon Christensen joins him with a kick drum and brushed snare approach to rhythm-making. Composer Jan Garbarek enters around the two minute mark with his own free-jazz stream of tenor sax playing. Jon settles into more full use of his drum kit as Arild and Jan continue flowing freely around him as if each in their own universes (though using a common tempo). At 4:15 Bobo joins in, taking a chromatic melody line that feels quite similar those used by his predecessors (Jan has now ceased to play). We are blessed that he even deigns to use some West-familiar chords in his piano poundings. I know it takes talent and skill to play this stuff but I don't enjoy the discomfort and irritation it puts me through. (13.125/15)

6. "Lontano" (2:10) Terje's lone composition is but another exploration of the unguitar-like sounds that a guitar can make. Is this really music? (3.75/5)

Total Time: 41:55

These Norwegian experimental Jazz musicians are already obsessed with the dominant place of space and the acoustics of such within their musical landscapes, stark as they are. Seeing that four of the six compositions (adding up to 90% of the album's duration) are Jan Garbarek compositions I can see why. I just don't enjoy chromatic structure (or is it more accurate to call it "lack of structure"?) Mathematical juxtapositions of music theory are fine in the head or practice room but to inflict it upon an unprepared, uneducated public is bordering on criminal--almost terroristic!

D-/1.5 stars; acerbic "music" that makes me want to run to Mother Nature or even AM radio for comfort and rehabilitation.

JAN GARBAREK Afric Pepperbird

Album · 1970 · Avant-Garde Jazz
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
FunkFreak75
Though listed as Jan's second album, his first with Manfred Eicher's ECM label, this is really an album of George Russell's The Esoteric Circle.

A1. "Scarabée" (6:15) kalimba, cymbals and other percussion play, long notes from a gentle saxophone, guitar chords, all building very slowly--like the discoveries in a detective spy novel. Impeccable sound rendering of music that seems to go for an effect, a setting, more than a structured song. Not the kind of musical listening experience (or even participatory experience) that I enjoy--unless in an Orff music class with the preschoolers and kindergarteners. (8.25/10)

A2. "Mah-Jong" (1:50) bass, cymbals, bass drum, snare drum, chromatic and dissonant guitar notes, chords and sounds, percussive play of other stringed instruments (like autoharp?). Intro to a Beatnik sit in. (4/5)

A3. "Beast Of Kommodo" (12:30) the first song that has some structural elements that I can hook into: Arild's adherence to a steady four-chord line of bass chords, Jon Christensen's cymbal and big tom interplay, Terje Rypdal's gentle finger-plucked guitar chords (complementing Arild's bass chords until the seventh minute when the two separate), and Jan's mellifluous and innocuous sax play. Once Terje's chord play deviates from Arild's, Arild and Jon really go off into their own lands (with Jan picking up some percussion along the way). It is truly remarkable how melodic Jon Christensen's drum play is: such a master and virtuoso! The rhythm section reins themselves back in (now playing a different pattern) while Jan picks up different instruments like flute and bent sax notes and Terje begins to express more in single notes and blues-rock chords à la John Tropea and Eric Gale. Overall I find myself really liking this: more for the skills on display and non-discordant melodies the individuals choose to employ. The odd 30-second bass and flute finale is weirdly sliced onto the end for reasons I know not. (22.5/25)

B1. "Blow Away Zone" (8:35) more odd percussion work as Jon Christensen "splits himself" into half cymbalist, half tom-tom player. Terje's unconventional scraping of his guitar strings and odd striking/strumming of the non-fretted parts of his guitar strings takes the lead for a bit before Jan enters playing a crochety old bass sax with minimal care for the initial sounds he's creating. Eventually he reins it in and starts playing clearer notes and runs while Arlid's bass walks aimlessly around the fretboard, but Jan continues to mix in the scratchy, screechy atonal notes while Jon continues exploring his own Venn overlap of cymbals and toms and Terje continues playing parts of his guitar that aren't meant to play pleasant ear-charming music. Around the 6:00 minute mark every one stops to watch (I don't imagine they're drawn to listen) as Jan's screeching goes completely off the charts: sounding more like scared/dying seals, walruses, mandrills, and baboons than saxophones. Then everybody rejoins to contribute their own alien animal language inputs to bring the "song" to a close. The skill level and command of their instruments are extraordinary; the music not so much. (17/20)

B2. "MYB" (1:50) Beatnik bass, soft malleted toms and brushed snare, bent note guitar, and toneless, melody-less sax. Okay: where's the poet. (4/5)

B3. "Concentus" (0:47) like a top notch orchestra pit tuning and coming into entrainment. (4.5/5)

B4. "Afric Pepperbird" (8:00) I can definitely hear structure in this song: a set drum pattern, a melodic repeating bass line, rhythmic and melodic guitar and sax play. Overall, quite an enjoyable and image-evoking music experience. (13.5/15)

B5. "Blupp" (1:05) toms, sticks, and bird-like human-made vocal blips, all syncopated as if played by a trio of curious chimpanzees. (4.25/5)

Total Time: 41:27

As praised and acclaimed as this album is I cannot for the life of me pinpoint why--unless it is The Esoteric Circle's disdain for known forms, sounds, and structures while virtually eschewing the avant garde "free jazz" or "third stream" (perhaps expressing a little nostalgic holdover from the lost era of the Beat Generation).

C/three stars; I'm sure the musical knowledge and skill necessary to play this stuff is off the charts, but this is no music for me--and it is definitely nowhere near anything that fuses "rock 'n' roll" with "jazz" music!

JAN GARBAREK Ragas And Sagas (Ustad Fateh Ali Khan & Musicians From Pakistan)

Album · 1992 · World Fusion
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
Moshkiae
Jan Garbarek Ragas and Sagas 1992

With Ustad Fateh Khan (voice), Shaukat Hussain (tablas), Nazim Ali Khan (sarangi), Deepika Thathaal (voice) and Manu Katche (drums).

This is the area where a lot of Jan Garbarek's work fits really well ... as a raga, or as the definition describes it, some kind of framework for the improvisation to take place, and end up creating some music. One might even suggest that the opening parts are to be a part of the whole thing later, together as one piece. You don't exactly get that here on this album as the pieces are all well defined and put together, even if it is all improvisation, which I think it is ... though I'm not used to these things in a foreign language of music, which a lot of the different things out there in the middle east and far east of this world, certainly are, and not exactly appreciated in Western circles of the arts.

I don't think I can describe the different 5 pieces of music, which ought to tell you how acquainted I am with a lot of foreign music, though I probably listen to more of it than most folks that tend to stay with the more familiar things on radio and disk, that are listed in many publications, for example.

This is an album to be listened to, and not ... discussed, is just about all I can say, and the idea that Jan Garbarek can fit himself into and with these folks, is rather neat and special ... it's rare that you see such socializing in the arts, although I would think that Jan Garbarek's touch in the music is much more suited for these kinds of things than the metronomic nothings in so much rock music and even jazz out there. And Ustad Fateh Khan's vocal abilities are indeed special and rather amazing, even as you might think that during a moment in the RAGA II piece his voice is synthesized, but nope ... it is clear that it is not ... but sure grabs how we have come to listen and identify things in music ... until one day, we hear something that is not what we think ... I have to say ... far out!

Very nice work and special in its own way ... and the saxophone excursions do not exactly feel over done here since this is the point in a lot of this style of music in the East ... it's what made the Ragas famous, even though our ideas of what a Raga is, is very different ... but it's safe to state that the process in rock and jazz do not exactly allow for things to be this open and non-stop ... too much of the westernized music in the past 60 years has been centered on the "song" idea, and this is something that is not a part of the Raga ... I was once told that if a Raga was under an hour, it was no Raga ... and that ought to give yo an idea of the limitations that go home in these pieces ... and it becomes wide open to the interpretation in our Western minds, that don't know this music intimately, and in this case Jan Garbarek seems to have very little to hang on to, other than some vocal moments that are likely pre-defined that help Jan Garbarek add something to the whole piece. A good example, would be the Raga III piece.

A special album, and something that only ECM ever did, allow for its folks to do a lot of work on their own, and sometimes it worked and others it sound more conventional, but at moments like this one in this album the whole thing just goes somewhere that we can nt exactly define and experience ... but might become clearer as we listen to these things more and more.

NOTE: If you are into "jazz", this album is not for you, I don't think. If you are into the experiment of hos a jazz player can mix and match with something else, then this album is outstanding in that idea and comes though shining brightly. A wonderful touch ... and I might even say a rare touch!

JAN GARBAREK All Those Born With Wings

Album · 1987 · Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
Moshkiae
Jan Garbarek All Those Born With Wings 1987

Sometimes, reviewing an album is difficult ... and sometimes, I can see why some folks would rather an album fit something or other so it would be easier to say something about it ... and guess what we have here? What is it? Where does it fit?

Jan Garbarek plays all the instruments in this album, and if anything is special here it is that the whole thing is really quiet and all of these are simply named First through Sixth Pieces ... with the "Third Piece" being a dirge, if we are taking the hint from the album notes.

I will likely suggest that anyone listening to this album, do not expect to get "jazz" in many of the styles and forms that we are used to. Like many albums of his in this period, which I call "middle period", they are about moods and thoughts that arise from a piece of music ... and it is very clear and obvious that the idea here is the illumanation of the idea and visual that drives the music ... and thus, it never falls into any kind of idealistic form of jazz or attitude ... I think the only thing here, in this album is that the piece live on its own and sound nice at the same time ... no need to worry about the nice part ... all of these pieces stand up nicely ... with that third piece being the one that is most obvious as to what it tries to make us think.

One of the pieces that stands out the most is probably the longest one in this album, called "Fifth Piece" and it is the one where Han Garbarek drives his saxophone the most, but remember that he is also playing the guitar here, and anything elsse that is needed for his piece of music ... it feels adventurous, as the piece develops and we might even consider "strange", waiting for the saxophone, and where it is going, though I'm not sure that it matters, if you simply close your eyes and follow along, which is what this album is really all about,

I want to caution as to the ideas and thoughts regarding this album and what/where the music is supposed to be taking us, which I am inclined to believe is not a part of Jan Garbarek's intent on this album at all, and he might be trying to do some things (witness the later parts of the saxophone in the 5th piece) that appeal to him, but would not necessarily fit a group or a designed piece of music for various players ... I think his relief here is that he doesn't have to worry about anyone else, and he can try different things all around, and I suppose that we could say some work, and some don't ... but in all honesty, it will probably be a rarity that yo get a "jazz" album that lives like this one does ... if it doesn't stretch what jazz is, then, our imaginations are lost and not able to appreciate music, like they say art for art's sakes, though I'm not sure that I would ever think of Jan Garbarek as that kind of player at all ... maybe in his early days, but from the sound of these pieces, I think there is an idea ... about coloring music, that jazz usually gives up on when it begins the timing and the drumming ... just like its cousin rock music does ... always tied to the time keeping, and then having to use lyrics to convince us of its ideas ... the worst idea of all when it comes to these things, since at any given time, you and I would think something else.

A wonderful album ... difficult to describe ... but just think of it as a quiet night in the middle of nowhere, trying to find who and what you are, instead of thinking you and I already know all this and don't need to hear about it anymore. The arts are about waking up the imagination, not regurgitating the ideas and imagination like a lot of lyrics do in rock music, something I really like about most jazz ... let the music fly, with or without wings, and that might just be what all this is about. A well defined title for this album.

Very very nice album ... and special in its own way. A rare treat regardless of where folks place this album, but it might be best to say ... this is not jazz ... this is a sort of thoughts from the universe somewhere.

JAN GARBAREK Eventyr

Album · 1981 · Chamber Jazz/Lite Fusion
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
Moshkiae
Jan Garbarek Eventyr 1981

With Nana Vasconcellos and John Abercrombie

Sometimes, I wonder if some of these things are really jazz, even though many of the players are almost exclusively jazz wisened and practiced.

This middle period of Jan Garbarek's is interesting ... not sure you can call it much of anything other than "ambient", as you never really get that feeling that the players are going to break out and jam on their instruments. With Nana Vasconcellos doing his thing on various percussive instruments, and John Abercrombie adding some very light (and beautiful) touches to what Jan Garbarek is doing, and the best part of it ... they keep it going, very smoothly.

This is a special album, for me ... the opening is one of the nicest things I have ever heard and felt ... it has a calling f some sort, and it sounds very lonely, and not quite desperate, but you can feel the emotion with the call. Soria Maria is a Norwegian tale, and even though we might not know what that story is, you get the feeling that you know it some by the piece of music. It's beauty is a bit on the side of the likes of a siren's call in the old greek stories, it has a bit of an inebriated feel to it, or at least a bit on the person being affected if not by stimulants, then by the desire to do what the hero has to do in the story.

It feels like you have been enchanted while listening to it ... forget music ... just close your eyes and see if you can find the visual for it ... I think it gives us the terrain and the majority of the feeling surrounding it. It was, thought of as a "new age" type album, but with all due respect, that is not even a good suggestion in my book. The music here is way and far above a lot of that stuff that was created simply with a name on it to sell, and had not half as much an image as the stuff in this album does.

The whole album is fantastic, and not of the pieces are weaker or not as vivid as any of the others, although none of them have the incredible wake up call that Soria Maria has, which is very strong, and gets stronger as Nana Vasconcellos augments the piece with some of his drums very lightly ... this adds a bit of "distance" to your view of it, but it does not take away from the piece, the story of which has some long voyages.

The title, as it turns out, and I did not know it until I tried to look for a definition just as I am writing this is defined as "a bold or exciting undertaking or experience" ... and well, I think that is all you need to know to enjoy this album of fantastic music. It is a far out experience, and not always something that many of us take on, specially with a soundtrack!!!

The long pieces, (Soria Maria, Eventyr, Once Upon the Time, East of the Sun and West of the Moon) are all the special things here, and just about, all you need to listen to, but please don't do that ... this album deserves a full listen, as the smaller pieces might be thought of as simpler ... with the longer pieces all "a story" and it is my thought that it was Jan Garbarek's idea to tell a story, with the playing, and I think it succeeds well ... most jazz is not about a story ... it is ... here we go, and then each person does their thing and meet up somewhere in the end ... but here, as a piece is coming to an end, you want more ... even though I kinda think that some folks might consider this whole album a bit somber ... a soundtrack for an imaginary story ... a fable from the Norwegian history.

An album worth having, if you are a fan of folks experimenting well and trying to do something different than just play notes and chords a la jazz style ... this is about the mood and its continuation here, that defines this album ... and if you like that ... this is just fine.

Excellent work, and a part of a period of Jan Garbarek, that I think he was looking to see what could be done with jazz that was not so invisible as most jazz playing is, and so tightly based on notes and chords by most players. Hearing this, the first thought of mine ... was .. this is not "jazz" ... and I suppose that this is ambient, with a jazz like bend ... but that might be hard ... since you can close your eyes and this has a movie somewhere.

NOTE: Parts of this album was used in the film "JOURNEY OF HOPE" in 1990 a Swiss/Turkey film, about the plight of many refugees trying to get out of Turkey. The music in the film has Arild Anderson (not sure which album yet), Jan Garbarek and Terje Rypdal (from EOS) ... and it presents Xavier Koller's film with astounding images with various parts of the music, making it look like the music is about the hope that these folks have for a new life. It won an OSCAR for Best Foreign Film the following year.

JAN GARBAREK Movies Reviews

No JAN GARBAREK movie reviews posted yet.

JAN GARBAREK Shouts

Please login to post a shout
Moshkiae wrote:
1 year ago
Haven't seen any movies with him on it, although I think there is a video of him, Charlie Haden and Egberto Gismonti ... but other than that one pice from Eventyr and from EOS (Darling and Rypdal) were used in a film that won an Oscar for best foreign film. Sad film, but the music was used really well!
js wrote:
more than 2 years ago
The ECM CD lists it as a Jarrett album, so it has been moved to his discog. Anybody who rated the old entry can go ahead and rate it again.
Mssr_Renard wrote:
more than 2 years ago
I have this album in my collection, and I file it under Garbarek. By listening to it, it also belongs in the
'Garbarek'-category and not in the Jarrett-category. But I am not a big fan of both. Not a big fan of the whole ECM-sound, so I could and my be wrong.

I think I own it because of Jon Christensen, because I liked the album 'Blow Out'.

js wrote:
more than 2 years ago
Technically it could go either way, its all Jarret's music and this was called his European Quartet at the time. Some other sites give this album to Jarrett and some to Garbarek. I think either one is correct.
snobb wrote:
more than 2 years ago
Garbarek's name is stated first on the album's cover
karolcia wrote:
more than 2 years ago
Shouldn't 'Belonging be filed under Keith Jarrett?
idlero wrote:
more than 2 years ago
The arrangements are Garbarek's but I understand the rules
snobb wrote:
more than 2 years ago
You're twice right here - it's not much jazz, but main reason is it's Agnes Buen Gamas album,not Garbarek's. If it would be his album, it would be added without relation to genre, but now the only way to add it is if Agnes Buen Gamas would be approved for addition, what hardly happens.
idlero wrote:
more than 2 years ago
What about 'Rosenfole'? It is listed under Agnes Buen Gamas and it's not exactly jazz so probably she doesn't belong here, but it's still a Jan Garbarek collaboration
snobb wrote:
more than 2 years ago
changed
idlero wrote:
more than 2 years ago
Shouldn't 'Officium' be filed under Third Stream?
snobb wrote:
more than 2 years ago
agree - changed
idlero wrote:
more than 2 years ago
IMHO Mnemosyne belongs to Third Stream and not to World Fusion

JMA TOP 5 Jazz ALBUMS

Rating by members, ranked by custom algorithm
Albums with 30 ratings and more
A Love Supreme Post Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
Kind of Blue Cool Jazz
MILES DAVIS
Buy this album from our partners
The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady Progressive Big Band
CHARLES MINGUS
Buy this album from our partners
Blue Train Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
My Favorite Things Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
JazzMusicArchives.com has always relied on banners ads to cover web hosting fees and all.

Please consider supporting us by giving monthly PayPal donations and help keep JMA fast-loading and ad-free forever.

New Jazz Artists

New Jazz Releases

Wanderer Vocal Jazz
SARAH PILLOW
Buy this album from MMA partners
Memory Bomb RnB
KIEFER
Buy this album from MMA partners
Fluidity Nu Jazz
NILS PETTER MOLVÆR
Buy this album from MMA partners
Paintbox Classic Fusion
EMMA RAWICZ
Buy this album from MMA partners
More new releases

New Jazz Online Videos

The First Circle
SARAH PILLOW
js· 4 hours ago
The Oak Tree
EMMA RAWICZ
js· 1 day ago
More videos

New JMA Jazz Forum Topics

More in the forums

New Site interactions

More...

Latest Jazz News

members-submitted

More in the forums

Social Media

Follow us