FunkFreak75
Recorded at the Van Gelder Studio, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey on March 10, 1967, but Blue Note did not release this album until May of 1969. For this very popular album, all songs but "Kryptonite" are Wayne Shorter originals, the former was penned by wind player James Spaulding. A1. "Tom Thumb" (6:15) a salsa over which the soloists embellish the melodies as they feel inspired. I love this kind of melodic, rolling rhythm pattern. (9/10)
A2. "Go" (4:52) a nice slightly-Latinized rhythm pattern feeds and supports solos from James Spaulding on flute and Wayne on tenor sax (getting two segments) with Herbie providing the glue in between as well as a nice piano solo in the third minute and the sexy brass section working to help provide the bridges and the song's finish. I can't help but admit to feeling surprised at the limited (or absent) time in the spotlight given to the other band members--all of whom were quite capable and, I'm sure, willing. I do, however, hear the increased confidence and maturity in Wayne's own voice--something that perhaps he lacked a bit during his 20s. (8.875/10)
A3. "Schizophrenia" (6:59) a little bit of a rush to get into and through this one as Ron Carter and Joe Chambers speed along, Herbie doing his best to keep up with both punctuation and accents. Wayne takes the first solo before trombonist Curtis Fuller gets a turn, then James on his alto. Joe's ride cymbal work is so dominating that one can almost not hear any of his stick work on the skins much less the bass drum--until, that is, the end of the sixth minute when he finally breaks out (though not for a solo, just as a bridge to the next soloist: Herbie). Not Herbie's greatest solo, the chord work at the end is wonderful before the horn section rejoins to close the door on the end of the song. Competent and crisp if not totally engaging (much less mesmerizng). (13.5/15)
B1. "Kryptonite" (6:25) more fast-paced bass walking and ride cymbal races for James to play flute over for the first two minutes, the tempo lets up a little--from both Joe's cymbal stick and Ron's bass-walking pace--as James switches to his alto sax. I like the way he moves from longer notes to fast flourishes and diving and soaring runs. Herbie sneaks in during the fifth minute which evokes an odd slow down response from Ron--I mean, really slow--but then he jumps back into fast-walking during the second half of Herbie's solo (an awesome solo, by the way) before regulating his pace again a couple of times; It's as if he's driving in city traffic and has to be mindful of changes in the traffic patterns! I have to say that overall it just feels like a weirdly-constructed song. (8.875/10)
B2. "Miyako" (5:55) a beautiful and emotional love song for Wayne's first-born child, daughter Miyako. The song has been so analyzed and lauded for so many years that it seems rather pointless for me to express my own take, but it feels obvious that the arrival and presence of his daughter has brought Wayne no small measure of peace and serenity. It's gorgeous: fully deserving of all of the praise and accolades that have been thrown at it through the years. With the opening song, this is my favorite song on the album. (9.5/10)
B3. "Playground" (6:20) this unusual song serves as a stark contrast to the serene beauty of the previous song, and it is certainly playful--especially in the opening minute as the band is establishing the ground rules for such a loose and idiosyncratic song. Solos from Wayne and Curtis definitely convey the serious attitude toward concentrated play coming from each individual while Ron and Herbie seem to be fully engaged in the frivolous, even easy ADD distractability of playground presence. Joe Chambers seems to be expressing the most serious, hyperfocused attitudes--like he's all business on the playground--until the playfulness of Ron's bass, Wayne's horn, and Herbie's twinkle-toed piano solo start to stir him out of his robotic athleticism. Then it's all for himself as Herbie, Ron and Joe seem to be left alone playing off one another--though the horns rejoin, sometimes as a unit, sometimes fractioning off into individual silliness, before the producer/engineer starts to slow pull down the faders on the master, dimming everyone's fun. Interesting and, yes, kind of fun. (9/10)
Total Time: 36:38
While many reviewers I've found cite this album as either their favorite Wayne Shorter album, a revolutionary transitional album, or otherwise very important to Jazz and Wayne's personal evolution, I do not find it quite as engaging as several of his previous albums (two of which won't be released until 1979 and 1980, respectively). Wayne seems to be stingy with his gifts of giving the spotlight to his collaborators, even shutting them out on a few songs despite each their own impressive legacies. Also, I'm not quite as much of a fan of the shorter song formats as some of the longer layouts he allowed with previous recordings (including compositions he gifted to Miles Davis' albums during this period). I get the fact that he's older, more mature and composed with his own voice--and that his compositions have provided a launching pad for so many of his collaborators in the past--I just miss the more generous space he seemed to
A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of Jazz--perhaps the last Bop album we'll be hearing from the ever-evolving Wayne Shorter.