Straight11travis
Tyshawn Sorey’s recent engagement with the jazz tradition has never really been about repertory in the conventional sense. From Mesmerism onwards, familiar compositions have increasingly become material through which he can investigate duration, memory and the unstable relationship between written form and improvisation. With Members… Don’t! this process reaches one of its most ambitious realizations. Sorey takes Max Roach’s 1968 Members, Don’t Git Weary as his point of departure, but the distance between the two recordings is immediately apparent: Roach’s concise statement is expanded into a ninety-five-minute performance in which the original pieces are dismantled, stretched and reassembled within a very different conception of musical time.
This makes the idea of a “tribute” particularly inadequate. The historical and political significance of Roach’s album remains essential to the project, but Sorey does not preserve its music as an artifact of 1968. Instead, he seems interested in discovering what that material can still generate when placed within the language of contemporary improvisation. It is a characteristic attitude towards tradition: history is acknowledged precisely by refusing to leave it untouched. The connection between the social urgency surrounding Roach’s original and the present is therefore carried not only by the repertoire itself, but by the act of subjecting it to transformation. That sense of historical continuity is central both to Sorey’s stated conception of the project and to the critical reception of the album.
The transformation is above all temporal. “Abstrusions” and the eighteen-minute “Effi” introduce a procedure that will govern much of what follows. Themes are no longer necessarily the fixed centres around which improvisation develops; they become elements that can emerge from an already active musical environment, disappear into it and subsequently return in altered perspective. Sorey can establish a pulse without allowing it to become permanent, and rhythmic information continually passes between drums, Tyrone Allen II’s bass and Lex Korten’s piano. As a result, even passages that acquire considerable momentum retain an underlying instability. The music moves forward, but its direction is rarely predictable.
This also changes the listener’s perception of form. Instead of a succession of themes and solos, the album develops through changing densities. O’Farrill and Shim constitute an often incendiary front line, but the real architecture of the performance frequently emerges underneath them. Allen can anchor the ensemble and simultaneously leave enough harmonic space for its centre of gravity to shift, while Korten moves between accompaniment, counterpoint and an almost orchestral use of the piano. His importance becomes particularly evident as the performance expands: rather than simply filling the harmonic space between horns and rhythm section, he often helps determine how one area of the music can evolve into another. His contribution, especially in the second part of “Equipoise,” has also been singled out in the album’s critical reception.
The two-part “Equipoise” can consequently be heard as something close to the structural centre of Members… Don’t!. Across more than twenty-six minutes, the original composition becomes less an object to be interpreted than a field within which the ensemble negotiates different degrees of freedom. Episodes acquire shape, dissolve and are replaced by others without destroying the perception of an overall trajectory. This is one of Sorey’s particular strengths: extended duration does not merely mean that more things happen. It alters the hierarchy between musical events. A gesture that might have functioned as a transition in a shorter performance can become an environment of its own; conversely, thematic material can be reduced to a fleeting reference whose importance lies in what it triggers rather than in how completely it is stated.
Seen from this perspective, the album’s ninety-five minutes are fundamental to its expressive effect. The cumulative pressure generated by the group would be difficult to achieve through a series of self-contained performances. “Libra,” with its more explicit connection to post-bop energy, does not interrupt this process so much as intensify it. Sorey remains an imposing presence throughout, yet his authority is rarely exercised through simple rhythmic domination. His drumming continually regulates energy, density and space, allowing the ensemble to move between suspension and propulsion while preserving the sense that these contrasting states belong to the same large-scale design.
Everything ultimately points towards “Members, Don’t Git Weary.” By moving Roach’s title composition to the end of the sequence, Sorey gives it a weight that exceeds that of another reinterpretation within the program; it becomes the destination towards which the preceding music appears retrospectively to have been moving. All About Jazz Fay Victor’s arrival also introduces the human voice only after the instrumental ensemble has spent more than eighty minutes accumulating and transforming musical tension. Her performance brings gospel, blues, declamation and freer vocal gestures into the same expressive space. The effect is not one of returning safely to the language of the original album. Rather, the song gathers the preceding instability into something more direct and communal, until the tension between fragmentation and affirmation becomes the source of the closing performance’s considerable emotional force. Pitchfork similarly identifies this final convergence of disorder and blues-rooted clarity as the album’s decisive release.
What distinguishes Members… Don’t! is ultimately the way Sorey reconciles two ideas that might appear contradictory: respect for historical memory and refusal of formal preservation. Roach’s album remains recognizable as the project’s cultural and musical foundation, yet almost everything concerning scale, pacing and internal organization belongs to Sorey’s world. The compositions survive not despite this process but through it. The result is demanding without being hermetic. Its extended durations require a different kind of attention from the listener, but they also make possible the gradual accumulation that gives the final section its extraordinary impact. More than a reimagining of a classic record, Members… Don’t! becomes an argument about what a jazz tradition can be: not a collection of forms to reproduce, but a body of musical experience capable of being questioned, destabilized and made necessary again.