IF

Jazz Related Rock • United Kingdom
Jazz music community with discographies, reviews and forums
IF picture
If was a seminal band formed in 1969 as Britain’s answer to the pioneering U.S. bands Blood, Sweat and Tears and Chicago. Unlike these groups, however, If did not have a trumpet or trombone player but instead featured two saxophone players. Essentially a live band, true to its strong jazz influences, If was one of the few jazz-rock groups, both then and now, to feature solos by all the band members, not just by the lead instruments. Like early pioneers Chicago, If were difficult to classify with any of their contemporaries; they seemed out of place wherever they played, and were considered too jazzy when billed with groups with more of a rock orientation, and too bluesy or loud when billed with more jazz-oriented bands. They toured extensively in Europe and the United States during the early 1970s, with two U.S. tours during their first year, performing at most of the major read more...
Thanks to EZ Money for the addition and snobb for the updates

Buy IF music

IF Online Videos

No IF online videos available. Search and add one now.

IF Discography

IF albums / top albums

IF If album cover 3.69 | 8 ratings
If
Jazz Related Rock 1970
IF If 2 album cover 3.55 | 4 ratings
If 2
Jazz Related Rock 1970
IF If 3 album cover 3.77 | 4 ratings
If 3
Jazz Related Rock 1971
IF If 4 album cover 3.05 | 2 ratings
If 4
Jazz Related Rock 1972
IF Waterfall album cover 3.75 | 2 ratings
Waterfall
Jazz Related Rock 1972
IF Double Diamond (aka Another Time Around aka This Is If) album cover 0.00 | 0 ratings
Double Diamond (aka Another Time Around aka This Is If)
Jazz Related Rock 1973
IF Not Just Another Bunch Of Pretty Faces album cover 0.00 | 0 ratings
Not Just Another Bunch Of Pretty Faces
Jazz Related Rock 1974
IF Tea-Break Over, Back on Your 'Eads! album cover 1.50 | 1 ratings
Tea-Break Over, Back on Your 'Eads!
Jazz Related Rock 1974
IF If 5 album cover 2.00 | 1 ratings
If 5
Jazz Related Rock 2016

IF EPs & splits

IF live albums

IF Europe '72 album cover 3.00 | 1 ratings
Europe '72
Jazz Related Rock 1997
IF Fibonacci's Number - More Live If album cover 0.00 | 0 ratings
Fibonacci's Number - More Live If
Jazz Related Rock 2010
IF If Live At The BBC album cover 0.00 | 0 ratings
If Live At The BBC
Jazz Related Rock 2022

IF demos, promos, fans club and other releases (no bootlegs)

IF re-issues & compilations

IF Forgotten Roads: The Best of If album cover 0.00 | 0 ratings
Forgotten Roads: The Best of If
Jazz Related Rock 1995
IF Not Just Another Bunch of Pretty Faces / Tea-break Over-Back on Your 'Eads album cover 0.00 | 0 ratings
Not Just Another Bunch of Pretty Faces / Tea-break Over-Back on Your 'Eads
Jazz Related Rock 2005

IF singles (0)

IF movies (DVD, Blu-Ray or VHS)

IF Reviews

IF If 2

Album · 1970 · Jazz Related Rock
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
FunkFreak75
The band must have put a lot of music in the can during the recording sessions that provided the material for the October release of their debut because this album, their second, was also released within the same calendar year as their debut! Thus the similarities in sound and production quality between this album and its predecessor. After the band's debut album rose quickly in the charts--in both the UK and the USA--the record companies must have felt rushed to take advantage of the window of popularity by pulling together this second album. And yet, the musicianship and compositional skill on display here seem even higher than the fine material on the debut. 1. "Your City Is Falling" (5:04) my premise of prediction offered in the opening intro to this review may have just been proved quite wrong by this song: the compositional demands of this song feel far more demanding than anything on the first album and the musicianship feels quite a step up from nearly everybody but especially from keyboardist John Mealing and drummer Dennis Elliott: the two are on fire! Quite the dynamic, even rousing, gem. A masterpiece of Jazz- Rock Fusion. The only weaknesses come from the Grand Funk Railroad-like lyrics/subject matter and vocal (or perhaps more accurately: the presence of vocals). (9.375/10)

2. "Sunday Sad" (8:18) Point Two in the disproval of my opening theory: the guitar tone selected by Terry Smith for the opening of this song is quite different than the one he settled into over the course of the song sequence of the debut album. The vocal and musical style presented here is very much in the wheelhouse of the great new emerging American Southern Rock bands--like Buffalo Springfield, The Band, and The Allman Brothers as well as Grand Funk or The Who. (17.5/20)

3. "Tarmac T. Pirate and the Lonesome Nymphomaniac" (5:12) reaching back to their Blues and Blues Rock roots we have The WHO with Roger Daltry and BLIND FAITH as the would be targets for emulation with this one. Decent rock but not really anything close to J-R Fusion. Nice Clapton guitar work, Terry! (8.75/10)

4. "I Couldn't Write and Tell You" (8:23) this one takes me back to Stevie Winwood's early days with The Spencer Davis Group (parts of this song feel lifted straight out of "Gimme Some Lovin'"). The band is so tight, the musicianship so well synchronized, it's almost enough! But, in the end, this is not the type of music that I run to. It is rather remarkable how often J.W. hits a note and I find myself thinking that I'me hearing Roger Daltry or Stevie Winwood (which definitely begs the question as to why this band didn't reach lasting international fame). I love the interplay between Terry's speedy lead guitar note-play, Jim Richardson's bass, and Dennis' stick-to-metal percussion play during the fifth thru seventh minutes. (17.75/20)

5. "Shadows and Echoes" (4:24) a little funky Soul music! I am impressed! This could easily have come out of some Philly, Chicago, or even Motown studio--at least, that is, the first two minutes! Then, around the two-minute mark, as J.W. winds up his singing portion of the song, the band high-tails it into the hills with jazzy instrumental passage of breath-taking speed, but this, sadly, only lasts a minute or less before the band returns to a recapitulation of the A-B sections for J.W.'s soulful finish. Fascinating! (9.125/10)

6. "Song for Elsa, Three Days Before Her 25th Birthday" (5:11) another bluesy WHO-like tune that stays a little more grounded in the Jazz-Rock that made their first album such a different delight: In fact, knowing the band's history (with sax player Dick Morrissey being the leader that holds the band together for as long as it did) how little solo or even "horn section" time he and David Quincy are occupying on this album. At least they get this one song! (8.875/10)

Total Time 36:32

The musicianship and compositional acumen are on the rise but the direction away from both Jazz-Rock Fusion and even Jazz-Rock has me feeling a bit disappointed.

B/four stars; an excellent collection of sophisticated Blues-Rock-based songs that show the band's movement more toward Pop-R&B than Jazz-Rock Fusion (or even Jazz-Rock).

IF If 3

Album · 1971 · Jazz Related Rock
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
FunkFreak75
Same lineup as the band's two 1970 releases. If 3 was recorded at Island Studios in the Spring of 1971 and then released by United Artists Records in the UK and Europe and Capitol Records in the US and Japan in August and September.

1. "Fibonacci's Number" (7:48) a Jazz-Rock instrumental that finds the band returning to the dynamic Jazz-Rock forms and styles that they had unleashed upon the world with their debut album (but had veered away from with their more poppy sophomore effort) only with much more sophistication, band tightness and maturity. Though this song sounds a bit like it expresses far more originality than (13.75/15)

2. "Forgotten Roads" (4:26) a return to the vocal stylings they had concentrated more on during their putting together of their second album, the music of this song retains all of the power, dynamics, energy, and high spirits of the best Jazz-Rock stuff. Guitarist Terry Smith continues to evolve with his skills and proclivity for speedy, technically-impressive solos. (8.875/10)

3. "Sweet January" (5:03) a slower ballad that sounds very much like something PROCOL HARUM could/would have done. Nice doubling up from John Mealing on the organ and piano while Dave Quincy and Dick Morrissey both take turns on both saxes and flutes. Nicely crafted pop- and stage-friendly song--one that represents the band's own production choices. (9/10)

4. "Child of Storm" (3:50) a DEEP PURPLE-like organ-led motif opens this as the whole band congeals with it and J.W. (now "John"?) sings above the horns, dynamic organ and solid rhythm section. There are elements of this song that deserve superlatives while, at the same time, there are a few notable engineering and timing weaknesses, which makes it really hard to rate. I really like this one despite its flaws. (9/10)

5. "Far Beyond" (4:59) opening with 15 seconds that sound a bit like 10CC's "I'm Not in Love" before we switch to stage right where the solo piano takes control of the music with John's vocal, making it feel much more like a 1970 West End/Broadway "showtune." It is a nice song, well constructed and emotionally engaging, but other than the "safe" rock guitar solo in the third minute, it is nothing really exceptional. A piano rocker pop tune. I do, however, wonder if Jon Anderson and YES ever saw (or heard) this band live as there are some familiarities to the music on Yes' second album, Time and a Word. (8.875/10)

6. "Seldom Seen Sam" (5:04) dipping into the sound and stylings of American band CREEDENCE CLEARWATER REVIVAL we have a solid Blues-Rocker that uses guitar and flute lines quite effectively to help form the matrix over which John sings in his less-than-usual nasally voice. Terry's guitar work--which is highlighted in a prolonged "C" instrumental passage--is quite in line with the stylings used by folk rock and Country-Western guitarists. (8.875/10)

7. "Upstairs" (4:44) heavy and thick with guitar and horn section power chords, the feeling here is like a cross between CHICAGO, COLOSSEUM, and PROCOL HARUM--this latter is especially true during the instrumental passages between John's vocals (which make up probably 80 percent of the song and are the best parts of the song). A rather dull, one-dimensional song that is elevated significantly by the South African-like guitar and bass lines played during the instrumental passages. Nice work from John Mealing on the organ as well as by Dave and Dick's saxes. (8.875/10)

8. "Here Comes Mr. Time" (4:45) this one cries out BLOOD, SWEAT & TEARS with its Rock/R&B syncopation and steady vocal performance and prominent horn section. Terry exhibits a fuzzy/distorted sound for his solo in the second and third minutes. John's vocal performance in the second half begins to sound so much like JON ANDERSON (especially with the application of those YES-like background vocal harmonies. A solid song but, like so many of the songs on this (and other IF albums), I can see why/how it gets forgotten. (8.875/10)

Total time: 40:37

I'm so glad to hear the band returning to the jazzier side of music with this Jazz-Rock album release. I am, again, continually surprised that this band is held together by one of the musicians who seems to have decreased his role in the songs since their debut: saxophonist Dick Morrissey. Also, as solid of a singer is J.W. "John" Hodgkinson, his weakness (and, probably, his ultimate forgettability) is due to a lack of that "something special."

B+/4.5 stars; a near-masterpiece of skilled songs and performances captured with proficient engineering and production showing growth and maturation but, like much of the music of its comparable Jazz-Rock representatives, Blood, Sweat & Tears and Chicago, somehow lacking a necessary "it" factor to take them to the next level of international stardom.

IF If

Album · 1970 · Jazz Related Rock
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
FunkFreak75
British Jazz-Rockers whose career lasted four years during which they were able to produce three very solid Jazz-Rock Fusion albums, starting with this one. The band's debut album was released in the UK by Island Records in October of 1970, in the US by the Capitol label.

1. "I'm Reaching Out on All Sides" (5:14) a simple straight Blues song that the band tries to jazz up with its horns in the fashion of bands like Blood, Sweat & Tears and Chicago though one can definitely hear the influence of any band the Steve Winwood has participated in by this time (The Spencer Davis Group, Traffic, Blind Faith). The music slowly increases in intensity over the opening three minutes, even as singer J.W. Hodgkinson sings in an Alex Ligertwood-type or Roger Wootton-like sound and style, building up a and somewhat unsettling or 'scary' hypnotic effect, but then, in the fourth minute, the two saxes appear with emphatic punctuation accents in the style and tradition of the famous MEMPHIS HORNS to take us into an even-more psychedelic WHO-like motif (complete with a PETE TOWNSEND-like singing voice). The effect of this two-person horn section is powerful enough to make me re-listen to the song over and over to uncover how, in fact, the band is achieving such an impressive "full horn" effect. (9/10)

2. "What Did I Say About the Box, Jack?" (8:20) despite a dynamic and powerful flute-and-sax-led Jazz-Rock opening and an ensuing "I'm a Man"-like organ chord progression over which composer Dick Morrissey performs quite a wild and enthusiastic flute solo, the main body of this song is built over organist John Mealing's four chord minor blues progression--a progression that was obviously borrowed from fellow Brit guitarist Peter Green's Latin-Blues songs "I Loved Another Woman" (from Fleetwood Mac's self-titled debut album) and "Black Magic Woman" (which was somewhat borrowed from John Mayall & The Blues Breakers' version of Otis Redding's "All Your Love" two years previously), the latter of which first appeared as a single, released by Fleetwood Mac in March of 1968--long before it became a household name via SANTANA's Abraxis album (both released in the Autumn of 1970). The Latinized minor blues chord progression then becomes the support bed for guitarist Terry Smith's extended lead, the two-sax "horn section"'s accents, and, later, some smooth sax soloing to take us well into the seventh and eighth minutes. I have to say that I am impressed with the way these guys can cobble together a song! (18.125/20)

3. "What Can a Friend Say?" (6:28) switching to a slightly-muted guitar tone, Terry Smith gives us an excellent STEPHEN STILLS impression on his lead guitar as the band establishes a very full, very dynamic Jazz-Rock motif for a vocal performance that reminds me of MURRAY HEAD in the iconic role of Judas in Andrew Lloyd-Weber's Jesus Christ Superstar. A very aggressive tenor sax solo takes over the lead in the middle of the song, presenting a very strong, very spirited performance as the equally-inspired rhythm section pushes and propells the music along in quite the BLOOD, SWEAT & TEARS fashion. Again, a powerfully-designed and amplified Jazzed-up Rock song. (9.125/10)

4. "Woman, Can You See (What This Big Thing Is All About)?" (4:01) Side Two begins with another blues-based chord progression and melody line that is elevated by speed and power of the musicians' dynamic energy. Solid and powerful. (9/10)

5. "Raise the Level of Your Conscious Mind" (3:11) using the Jazz-Rock medium to elevate the spiritual wisdom of the Hippie Age! It's as if the L.A. positivity is being taken over by the San Francisco blues-rock scene. I like the message: I can see it being effective as a medium for gaining audience participation (which was, apparently, one of the band's strenghts). (8.75/10)

6. "Dockland" (5:21) here again I find the band trying to tap into the social-political consciousness that musicians all over America were trying to squeeze into: CROSBY, STILLS, NASH & YOUNG and THE ASSOCIATION. It's good but now feeling rather dated. The final minute shows the band picking up from one of their previous songs--where the vocalist seems to want to sing about important things in a form most familiar to the radio world via the music coming from West End/Broadway-like stage musicals. (8.875/10)

7. "The Promised Land" (4:31) the hippie spirit of consciousness raising is again felt rather strongly in both the lyrics and the uplifting theatric/Christian music Singer J.W. Hodgkinson certainly comes across as feeling genuine in his backing of the lyrics he's singing. Heck! The whole band continues to come exploding through any haze or lethargy with their amazingly intrepid performances! (And, yes, I love the Stephen Stills guitar tone Terry has decided to settle into over the course of the second half of the album--since "What Can a Friend Say?".) (8.75/10)

Total Time 37:06

The band was obviously made up of experienced, well-trained musicians, at the same time it is equally obvious that they are rising out of the UK's well-steeped Blues/Blues-Rock scene. What I find most remarkable about the music on this album is the songwriters' abilities to cobble together riffs, themes, and styles borrowed from or inspired by other songs, bands, and musicians while rendering them interesting, layered, and each song multi-varied/multi-movement. It's still a mystery to me how this band & production crew got the powerful horn section sound out of two saxophone players!

B+/4.5 stars; a near-masterpiece of Jazz-Rock that I'm almost ready and willing to bump up to masterpiece status based upon the consistently upbeat power and force of its music and mature whole-band performances.

IF If 4

Album · 1972 · Jazz Related Rock
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
Sean Trane
If’s discography is not that simple because of the different release not getting the same artwork on simply not getting a release, this phenomenon reaches its apex with their fourth release, which is more or less the “Waterfall” European release (not sure of this though) and this album sports at least two different artworks (one black/silver and one red/white, that I’ve seen so far). In either case, the line-up has remained stable; including the present album, but it will soon suffer its first and only change (but a major one) after the release of this one. . .

In itself the succession of tracks is already a bit bizarre, as there are some live tracks and studio tracks and the way they get stuck together is highly disputable

The opening Sector 17 track (a 10-mins+ instrumental) is probably the one most likely to please progheads with its fuzzed out bass, searing guitar, excellent alternating sax solos, and not forgetting the usual brass section, etc…. we could be in a Soft Weather Nucleus Mahavishnu Forever album. Maybe If’s best track with Fibonacci on the previous album and ending in a Colosseum-esque fashion. The following Light Still Shines is bringing us back down to earth after such tremendous start, with the average sung track that brings us back almost to BS&T (well I said almost) and slightly lengthy as well. The track Your Small Corner doesn’t have the full-horn section aggression of its predecessor, but it’s not that strong a tune either, some parts in the chorus sounding lifted, but I fail to see where.

The flipside starts with the flute-laden Waterfall, which will directly please progheads better, but it’s also a more challenging songwriting we face here and its cool psychy flute solo. Up next is Throw Myself To The Wind, which is rather pedestrian in its construction, but the middle section is good. The closing cover of Svenska Soma (I image Swedish Summer) is the second highlight of the album with Mealing’s organ drawing the glory here, but the whole band is shining, but not as hard as in Sector 17. Please note that two tracks on the flipside were apparently recorded live, including the closing one.

After the release of their best albums, If will implode and leaving the two sax players Morrissey and Quincy to rebuilt from scratch, and looking for a record deal. They will succeed , releasing two further albums (on Gull Records) with unlikely names under a fairly different sounding line-up (including future Procol member Geoff Whitehorn and Magno on keys), but the charm was broken. Returning to their fourth album, this is their better album, and it’s a shame things broke down at this point. While it’s difficult to give a “better’ album to start with, it’s clearly the UA label albums that are the better ones.

IF If 3

Album · 1971 · Jazz Related Rock
Cover art Buy this album from MMA partners
Sean Trane
Unchanged line=up for this septet that released their third album in early , but on a different label called United Artist, thus abandoning one of the proggiest of labels, Islands, although the recording sessions took place at Islands Studios. With another gatefold sleeve, this time emphasising the UA logo on the back cover, 3 features all original compositions although, strangely enough, they used an outside lyricist for most tracks: Trevor Preston, already seen on one track of their second album.

Starting on the enthralling instrumental Fibonacci’s Number, the album gets a really strong start, with the following Forgotten Roads, which was to prove their biggest hits (most notably in Germany). Both tracks are still much in the CTA or BS&T style, although the next Sweet January takes on a more soulish tone in the BS&T and Electric Flag style, even if the flute brings a noble touch. Child Of Storm returns to a better RnB with some excellent jazzy solos, most notably Morissey’s awesome alto sax, the track ending in a great thunderbolt.

The flipside gets a Lighthouse-like start (yes, Skip Prokop’s Canadian brass rock group Lighthouse) with the cheesy (mostly due to the chorus) Far Beyond (the flipside of the Forgotten road single, both tracks included as pointless bonus here), Seldom Seen Sam is returning to amore comfy RnB with some rather expert soloing from Mealing’s electric piano, but Smith’s twang-ey closing guitar parts are just not cutting it. The following Upstairs uses a cool organ and massive horn section answering lines. The closing Mr Time uses some more organ moans, this time in a Dave Greenslade and Rod Argent manner with Steve Smith’s guitar getting an extra notice, and develops from a slow start with some clever chord changes; it would be one of the album’s best track but vocally the track is just average.

As mentioned above, the bonus tracks are a pointless bonus, but 3 remains among the group’s best works, and certainly the last of their better ones, 4 being a weird release, sometimes as a studio album, sometimes as a live album, depending which country you were in. So, if you like If’s early stuff, this one should be absolutely no problems either.

IF Movies Reviews

No IF movie reviews posted yet.

IF Shouts

Please login to post a shout
No shouts posted yet. Be the first member to do so above!

JMA TOP 5 Jazz ALBUMS

Rating by members, ranked by custom algorithm
Albums with 30 ratings and more
A Love Supreme Post Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
Kind of Blue Cool Jazz
MILES DAVIS
Buy this album from our partners
The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady Progressive Big Band
CHARLES MINGUS
Buy this album from our partners
Blue Train Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
My Favorite Things Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
JazzMusicArchives.com has always relied on banners ads to cover web hosting fees and all.

Please consider supporting us by giving monthly PayPal donations and help keep JMA fast-loading and ad-free forever.

New Jazz Artists

New Jazz Releases

Wanderer Vocal Jazz
SARAH PILLOW
Buy this album from MMA partners
Memory Bomb RnB
KIEFER
Buy this album from MMA partners
Fluidity Nu Jazz
NILS PETTER MOLVÆR
Buy this album from MMA partners
Paintbox Classic Fusion
EMMA RAWICZ
Buy this album from MMA partners
More new releases

New Jazz Online Videos

The First Circle
SARAH PILLOW
js· 4 hours ago
The Oak Tree
EMMA RAWICZ
js· 1 day ago
More videos

New JMA Jazz Forum Topics

More in the forums

New Site interactions

More...

Latest Jazz News

members-submitted

More in the forums

Social Media

Follow us