IF — If 2 (review)

IF — If 2 album cover Album · 1970 · Jazz Related Rock Buy this album from MMA partners
3.5/5 ·
FunkFreak75
The band must have put a lot of music in the can during the recording sessions that provided the material for the October release of their debut because this album, their second, was also released within the same calendar year as their debut! Thus the similarities in sound and production quality between this album and its predecessor. After the band's debut album rose quickly in the charts--in both the UK and the USA--the record companies must have felt rushed to take advantage of the window of popularity by pulling together this second album. And yet, the musicianship and compositional skill on display here seem even higher than the fine material on the debut. 1. "Your City Is Falling" (5:04) my premise of prediction offered in the opening intro to this review may have just been proved quite wrong by this song: the compositional demands of this song feel far more demanding than anything on the first album and the musicianship feels quite a step up from nearly everybody but especially from keyboardist John Mealing and drummer Dennis Elliott: the two are on fire! Quite the dynamic, even rousing, gem. A masterpiece of Jazz- Rock Fusion. The only weaknesses come from the Grand Funk Railroad-like lyrics/subject matter and vocal (or perhaps more accurately: the presence of vocals). (9.375/10)

2. "Sunday Sad" (8:18) Point Two in the disproval of my opening theory: the guitar tone selected by Terry Smith for the opening of this song is quite different than the one he settled into over the course of the song sequence of the debut album. The vocal and musical style presented here is very much in the wheelhouse of the great new emerging American Southern Rock bands--like Buffalo Springfield, The Band, and The Allman Brothers as well as Grand Funk or The Who. (17.5/20)

3. "Tarmac T. Pirate and the Lonesome Nymphomaniac" (5:12) reaching back to their Blues and Blues Rock roots we have The WHO with Roger Daltry and BLIND FAITH as the would be targets for emulation with this one. Decent rock but not really anything close to J-R Fusion. Nice Clapton guitar work, Terry! (8.75/10)

4. "I Couldn't Write and Tell You" (8:23) this one takes me back to Stevie Winwood's early days with The Spencer Davis Group (parts of this song feel lifted straight out of "Gimme Some Lovin'"). The band is so tight, the musicianship so well synchronized, it's almost enough! But, in the end, this is not the type of music that I run to. It is rather remarkable how often J.W. hits a note and I find myself thinking that I'me hearing Roger Daltry or Stevie Winwood (which definitely begs the question as to why this band didn't reach lasting international fame). I love the interplay between Terry's speedy lead guitar note-play, Jim Richardson's bass, and Dennis' stick-to-metal percussion play during the fifth thru seventh minutes. (17.75/20)

5. "Shadows and Echoes" (4:24) a little funky Soul music! I am impressed! This could easily have come out of some Philly, Chicago, or even Motown studio--at least, that is, the first two minutes! Then, around the two-minute mark, as J.W. winds up his singing portion of the song, the band high-tails it into the hills with jazzy instrumental passage of breath-taking speed, but this, sadly, only lasts a minute or less before the band returns to a recapitulation of the A-B sections for J.W.'s soulful finish. Fascinating! (9.125/10)

6. "Song for Elsa, Three Days Before Her 25th Birthday" (5:11) another bluesy WHO-like tune that stays a little more grounded in the Jazz-Rock that made their first album such a different delight: In fact, knowing the band's history (with sax player Dick Morrissey being the leader that holds the band together for as long as it did) how little solo or even "horn section" time he and David Quincy are occupying on this album. At least they get this one song! (8.875/10)

Total Time 36:32

The musicianship and compositional acumen are on the rise but the direction away from both Jazz-Rock Fusion and even Jazz-Rock has me feeling a bit disappointed.

B/four stars; an excellent collection of sophisticated Blues-Rock-based songs that show the band's movement more toward Pop-R&B than Jazz-Rock Fusion (or even Jazz-Rock).

Review Comments

Post a public comment below | Send private message to the reviewer
Please login to post a shout
No shouts posted yet. Be the first member to do so above!

JMA TOP 5 Jazz ALBUMS

Rating by members, ranked by custom algorithm
Albums with 30 ratings and more
A Love Supreme Post Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
Kind of Blue Cool Jazz
MILES DAVIS
Buy this album from our partners
The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady Progressive Big Band
CHARLES MINGUS
Buy this album from our partners
Blue Train Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
My Favorite Things Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
JazzMusicArchives.com has always relied on banners ads to cover web hosting fees and all.

Please consider supporting us by giving monthly PayPal donations and help keep JMA fast-loading and ad-free forever.

New Jazz Artists

New Jazz Releases

Wanderer Vocal Jazz
SARAH PILLOW
Buy this album from MMA partners
Memory Bomb RnB
KIEFER
Buy this album from MMA partners
Fluidity Nu Jazz
NILS PETTER MOLVÆR
Buy this album from MMA partners
Paintbox Classic Fusion
EMMA RAWICZ
Buy this album from MMA partners
More new releases

New Jazz Online Videos

The First Circle
SARAH PILLOW
js· 5 hours ago
The Oak Tree
EMMA RAWICZ
js· 1 day ago
More videos

New JMA Jazz Forum Topics

More in the forums

New Site interactions

More...

Latest Jazz News

members-submitted

More in the forums

Social Media

Follow us