Matti P
Sting's second album received very good reviews and is definitely a pop classic today. It was a double vinyl -- three songs on each side -- although only 55 minutes long, which feels slightly too little. Since it contains some tracks that I rather skip, personally I feel this would make a truly marvelous single vinyl album.
Kenny Kirkland (keyb) and Branford Marsalis (sax) played also on Sting's debut in 1985. Manu Katché is the excellent drummer here and Sting himself makes a full return as a bassist. For the guitars this album has several guests: the former Police mate Andy Summers plays on the first two tracks. 'They Dance Alone' features Mark Knopfler, Fareed Haque and Eric Clapton (who also plays on 'We'll Be Together'), and some songs don't contain any guitars. This is not quite as much a band work as the albums surrounding it, especially The Soul Cages (1991), but that doesn't affect negatively to the whole. The production is fantastic, and the stylistic variety very rare and mature for the time of release.
'Lazarus Heart' is a cool, jazzy opener with a slight African feel in the sound. The romantically serene 'Be Still My Beating Heart' is lovely, one of my all time Sting favourites -- and that list contains several tracks from this particular album! In his brief song-by-song liner notes Sting says he wrote 'Englishman in New York' for a friend "who moved from London to New York in his early seventies", and with a few lines paints a charming picture of the chap, without revealing him to be the gay icon Quentin Crisp. The jazzy song is a charmer, too. (Some of these texts offer important background information while some are less poignant, but a nice feature nevertheless.)
'History Will Teach Us Nothing' has an afro-like, reggae-ish sound. Musically this is slightly monotonous, but the two other pieces on the second vinyl side are notable classics. 'They Dance Alone (Cuega Solo)' deals with the sufferings under the Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet's regime between 1973 and 1990. The album's longest track at 7:16, it really goes under one's skin emotionally. Rubén Blades reads the lines in Spanish. And 'Fragile'... A sad, serene song of magical beauty. Sting handles the acoustic guitar perfectly in it.
The third side is where I lose my interest. 'We'll Be Together' is a noisy, funky upbeat song. To many listeners it probably gives the needed spine since most of the album is soft and sensitive, but I just don't like it. 'Straight to My Heart' and 'Rock Steady' are simply boring to me.
The 11-minute final side is highly pleasant. 'Sister Moon' is an equivalent to the debut's 'Moon Over Bourbon Street' as a serene, nocturnal jazz ballad with a peaceful arrangement featuring Marsalis' sax. Unlike the earlier album reviewer here, I enjoy the dreamy version of 'Little Wing' a lot. Perhaps it helps that Jimi Hendrix and his original don't mean much to me. Sting is backed by Gil Evans and His Orchestra, joined by Hiram Bullock on the electric guitar solo. 'The Secret Marriage' is a peaceful 2-minute piano song based on a melody by Hanss Eisler, who escaped the Nazis like his colleague Bertolt Brecht.
It's a bit funny to rate an album that I love for 3/4 of it and sort of dislike for one quarter. Maybe 4 stars would reflect that.