JOHN ABERCROMBIE — Timeless

Jazz music community with discographies, reviews and forums

JOHN ABERCROMBIE - Timeless cover
3.99 | 20 ratings | 5 reviews
Buy this album from MMA partners

Album · 1975

Tracklist

A1 Lungs 12:09
A2 Love Song 4:35
A3 Ralph's Piano Waltz 4:56
B1 Red And Orange 5:24
B2 Remembering 4:32
B3 Timeless 12:00

Total Time 43:56

Line-up/Musicians

- John Abercrombie / guitar
- Jan Hammer / Hammond organ, synthesizer, piano
- Jack DeJohnette / drums

About this release

ECM Records ‎– ECM 1047 ST (Germany)

Recorded June 21,22 1974 at Generation Sound Studios, New York

Thanks to M.Neumann for the addition and snobb for the updates



Buy JOHN ABERCROMBIE - TIMELESS music

JOHN ABERCROMBIE TIMELESS reviews

Specialists/collaborators reviews

Abraxas
Check the line-up. What did you imagine? Wrong. Jan Hammer is mainly playing the organ throughout, so his Mahavishnu synth lines are almost inexistent. Ironically, John Abercrombie is the one that reminds us of Mahavishnu, with the often fast guitar licks. But mind you, this is not high fuelled jazz rock.

One thing you probably didn't notice was that this album belongs to the ECM label. And yes, this label shows its characteristic mellow, moody and cold sound, already by 1974. Its ECM, I think, that restrains John and the rest from doing anything really rock-ish. And that's a good thing. The remaining member of the trio being the widely known drummer, Jack DeJohnette.

The six compositions share the label's dark and mysterious mood, but some with more powder than others. Both 'Red and Orange' and 'Lungs' will make you doubt if what I'm saying is actually true, since these two are very force-driven with an exhilarating band, but still these have some elements that are not usually heard on say Mahavishnu Orchestra or Return to Forever.

'Love Song' and 'Remembering' however, are acoustic, piano and guitar only. These remind me a bit of Metheny's mellow acoustic affairs, a man well associated with ECM, or also Bill Connors' acoustic albums, also an associate from the label.

The title track couldn't be more ECM-ish. Twelve minutes of slow-moving music that has very subtle elements. Probably Jan Hammer's greatest intervention with the Moog in his entire career, creating channels of mystery and psychedelicness. One will either dismiss this for its lack of memorable melodies, or praise it for its unique atmosphere and progression.

Timeless isn't exactly "timeless", but it's unmistakably a noteworthy album in any wide jazz collection, being an interesting and smart link between post-bop, fusion and ECM jazz. Recommended with the guarantee of discovering something pretty fresh, though not exactly stunning.
M.Neumann
It's never a good thing for a critic to parade his ignorance, but in all honesty I can't tell you much about the life or career of guitarist John Abercrombie. All I know is that the title track of his 1974 debut solo album is, without exaggeration, one of the cornerstones of my entire music collection.

By itself this one cut is so compelling that for more than two decades it all but obliterated any interest I might have shown in the rest of the album. More fool me, because the entire package is an unassuming slice of pioneering musical Fusion, arranged by a guitar player who in a perfect world would be far better known outside the limited circle of Jazz Rock devotees.

The simple, no-frills production (not much more than a judicious application of reverb) leads me to suspect the bulk of the album was recorded live in the studio. Clearly the final mix benefits from the spontaneity of the performances, played by a gifted power trio able to employ as much nuance as muscle. Keyboardist Jan Hammer was of course an alumnus of the first and best MAHAVISHNU ORCHESTRA; drummer Jack DeJohnette attended the legendary Isle of Wight concert alongside a newly electrified MILES DAVIS; and Abercrombie himself was already a session veteran with a lengthy, impressive résumé.

The track list is perfectly balanced between two longer (but very different) pieces bracketing a quartet of shorter instrumentals. Among these are a pair of gentle piano / acoustic guitar duets, plus the intergalactic cocktail-lounge jazz of "Ralph's Piano Waltz" (with not a piano within earshot), and the harder-edged, hypertense fusion of Jan Hammer's "Red and Orange", built around a theme purloined from the classics. Another Hammer composition, the 12+ minute "Lungs", opens the album in a quiet frenzy of virtuosity, alternating with a more subdued, dreamlike interlude leading to an open-ended jazz-funk conclusion.

This leaves only the astonishing title track, a 12-minute masterpiece of otherworldly mood and invention, ending the album on maybe the warmest chillout in recorded history. Listen to that long opening drone, setting up a simple, haunting 12-note melody (actually only three notes, repeated in descending scales), with every carefully located sound bathed in blissful amniotic contentment. Is it Jazz? Space Rock? Ambient Electronica? A little bit of each and none of the above would be my closest guess.

Especially striking is the protracted entry of Hammer's mini-moog, fading in over the course of what sounds like several minutes (only a slight exaggeration), slowly embellishing Abercrombie's delicate picking and the typically fluid brushstrokes of DeJohnette's drumming. In short: here's a track that ably lives up to its title, having hardly aged a minute after more than 35 years.

Because this was an album that put a higher value on quality and competence over flashy pyrotechnics, it might have escaped the attention of discriminating listeners with an ear for Jazz Rock Fusion finesse. Trust me here, because I speak from experience: you don't want to allow half your life to slip away before treating yourself to this one.

Members reviews

Moshkiae1
John Abercrombie Timeless 1975

1. Lungs 2. Love Song 3. Ralph's Piano Waltz 4. Red and Orange 5. Remembering 6. Timeless

I have not heard this for quite some time, and this was one of the early first albums I got from ECM (after Gismonti), and it is a nice reminder of the special attitude and design that ECM offers many folks. Hard to think of this as some fusion but in the end, there are enough interesting moments here that showcase some rather nice stuff. And the surprise is how Jack DeJohnette fits in and John allows him all the time and effort, as Jan Hammer adds the slight touches here and there which leaves the piece more interesting. It starts out strong, but the best part is when it slows down and plays with the moods and ideas, which are neat and special. And this is just on the opener (Lungs) ... with a special feeling that this was done live, in the studio ... turn it on and go. Making those moments work is what special music is all about, and no riffing necessary!

One of the great highlights of this album is the difference in so much stuff ... and when you hear "Love Song", it's hard to not think that this is far out, and neat. There was no room in my head that this was not a real love song, and Jan Hammer's piano accompanyment, is far out, and in many ways one of my favorite things with his work. It isn't about what kind of thing it is, or what kind of music it is, it is about the particular feeling that this particular piece gives us, which is hard to not state that this is magical.

A nice thing, "Ralph's Piano Waltz" is interesting in that the title is misleading ... where is the piano? I suppose that the idea is to play the piece, as possibly a tribute to someone else's work, but the only piano you get here is the Hammond organ by Jan Hammer. A jazzy piece compared to the previous two, and as we find, so far, that's 3 for 3 ... all different! A very good listen, too!

"Red and Orange" is one piece that is a bit on the different side of things, maybe a bit more on the fusion side, with Jan Hammer taking a much bigger role on the keyboards. But don't think that John Abercrombie will be left behind, or that John DeJonhette is falling asleep ... heck, they add to this fusion thing some.

"Remembering" falls in the "Love Song" category, as your mind wonders what exactly is being remembered, but it has a slightly nostalgic feeling that is very much on par with things when we remember them years later ... and it is really nice to see this interpreted musically, and done beautifully, and Jan Hammer's piano is special here, all the way to the special ending.

The title piece "Timeless" is the one thing that you will remember from this album. It is a quiet and meditative piece and handled with a really nice touch on the guitar.

A wonderful example of the material that ECM created in its early years by allowing folks to just play what they did, and not second guess much, and in a piece like "Timeless" this ends up being super special and neat. The restraint on the playing by John Abercrombie is outstanding, and shows us that we have a guitar that "feels", not just play the notes and the over the top mechanics. And that was the irony of it all for ECM ... that sometimes, the simplest of things were the best mechanics of all ... and this album is one of those.

A wonderful listen and for once, you do not get that feeling that you are listening to jazz ... the feeling is that you are listening to MUSIC ... and that is always more special to our experience.
FunkFreak75
A guitarist that has been known to me since the 1970s due to his long association with ECM Records, it has only been recently that I've really come to know and appreciate his skill and genius as a technical wizard of both acoustic and electric guitar formats, as well as his high intelligence and creativity in conditions requiring structure, support, and improvisation. I am now unafraid to include John in the highest circle of jazz-rock fusion guitarists (with the likes of John McLaughlin, Jan Akkerman, Volker Kriegel, and Al Di Meola).

1. "Lungs" (12:08) organ and electric guitar trading incandescent flares for solos over some equally-stunning drum play. In the fourth minute, just as the two melody-makers start to really duel, the music slows down, spreads out, leaving a lot of space for some spacey organ and volume-controlled and echoed electric guitar note play while Jack gives a virtual clinic in cymbal and bass drum play which turns into a tom-tom and snare clinic as well. This is easily as powerful and virtuosic as anything the Mahavishnu Orchestra ever produced. At the beginning of the eighth minute the band resets and restarts with some kind of low-bass note play (from Jan Hammer, of course) providing a kind of funky rhythmic propulsion for Jan, John, and Jack to slowly, very deliberately, start contributing notes, riffs, and other idiosyncratic flourishes and musical catchphrases from here to the song's end. What this has to do with lungs, I'm not sure. (22.5/25)

2. "Love Song" (4:34) Jan Hammer's piano and John Abercrombie's acoustic guitar are here recorded performing a beautiful duet. These guys really hear each other--which is why this lovely conversation sounds so respectful and co- ordinated--like a dance--and not unlike something Chick Corea and Al Di Meola might have done together. (9.75/10)

3. "Ralph's Piano Waltz" (5:21) a more typical jazz swing with a great melody "hook" This is a John Abercrombie composition that became one of his signature songs--one that he re-recorded on several other studio albums and, of course, performed live with many of his bands--and I wouldn't understand anyone who wouldn't be able to "see" why. Great performance by John with awesome support from Jan's organ play and Jack's stunning drum play. Though I have great trouble thinking of Jack DeJohnette as a "fusion" drummer, he is definitely on the short list of the best jazz drummers I've ever heard (probably #1): his creativity is a marvel to behold. (9.375/10)

4. "Red In Orange" (5:21) a furious syncopated opening sounds like it could come from both EMERSON, LAKE AND PALMER or the MAHAVISHNU ORCHESTRA though the jazz guitar play ends up sounding more like JOHN TROPEA or ERIC GALE during the early section, the Larry Coryell in the fiery second section, and then like John McLaughlin in the photon-speed final minute. Jan Hammer's dynamic organ play sounds like LARRY YOUNG (Khalid Yasin)--especially when in support mode--but then he fires up some amazing Keith Emerson-like stuff in his duels with John--and Jack is right there with them the whole way! (9.625/10)

5. "Remembering" (4:32) back to piano and acoustic guitar dueting, this one meandering a little more like something from the Americana or Chick Corea school of austere acoustic or atmospheric duet music. Despite the flourishes of virtuosity, the key and tempo changes are met with ease with both musicians delivering gorgeous melodies and variations on those melodies throughout. Both musicians are showing their masterful ability to bring the listener back to the security of "home" by positing the occasional, perfectly-timed, dominant "comfort" chord. (Thank you!) There is, however, something very warm and humane about this song--this style of duet music--that feels more inviting and engaging--more personable--than the "competitive" duets that Al Di Meola became known for. (9.25/10)

6. "Timeless" (11:57) ominous low-end synth chord provides the steady foundation for John to noodle around improvisationally using a very gentle, soft tone on his electric guitar. I love this kind of electric guitar performance where volume and dynamic take a backseat to heart-felt feeling and sensitivity. In the fifth minute there is a transition into a section in which Jan sets forth a patterned bass line over which John plays off of with equally-interesting, beautiful fluidity and melodic sense. Jack joins the puff parade with his brushes, rarely beating anything dynamic, instead keeping to the same delicate sensibilities as his band mates. Jan is allowed to jump in a couple of times with his MiniMoog and the song never really changes or shifts or deepens again, just plays out with this same bass-line-led motif to the end. A nice exhibition of a certain kind of solo improvisational music but not a really engaging or deeply interesting song from a listener's standpoint. (22/25)

Total Time: 43:53

Jan Hammer has always come across as a much weaker keyboard player in my mind due to the fact that I've seen and heard mostly his performances where he is playing on either his stage "keytars" or dueling with guitarists and/or violins by using the right-hand upper registers of his computers, thus, I never thought the guy had a left hand. On several albums from the 1970s that I've stumbled across over the past couple of years I've been impressed to hear Jan Hammer as a more "complete" keyboard player: playing piano, organs, Fender Rhodes, Moogs, and, as here, lots of bass as a substitute for the more typical upright or electric bass player.

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of fringy jazz-rock fusion from three of Jazz-Rock Fusion's all-stars (two of which are lesser known). An album that I highly recommend to any prog lover who love it when virtuosic musicians can meld together really well.

Sean Trane
Having been part of the scene for some years, playing in various groups, but mostly for the Brecker Bros’ first band Dreams, Abercrombie finally attacked his fist studio album after getting a recording contract from ECM, with whom he would remain mostly fidel throughout his career. This debut album, like most of his first few albums are citing his

Abercrombie’s choice in DeJohnette (an ex-Bitches Brew drummer, but also very frequent Keith Jarrett sideman) will remain fairly constant in his early career, but it’s surprising not seeing Dave Holland (also ex BB and frequent Jarrett sideman) on bass here, but there is no bass at all (whatever might sound is most likely organ-pedalled by Hammer. The opening Hammer-penned Lungs is one of those scary 700 MPH, where ultra-sonic virtuosity is everything. Love Song is one of those boring slow track that are supposed to be the antidote to the demented tracks, but to me these sleeping pills are best skipped. Ralph’s Waltz (Towner of Oregon I guess) is at times enthralling, against which Hammer Red & Orange sounds captivating, but let’s be careful of Einstein’s Relativity theory here. R&O has some delightful moments, but I am saying moments, not minutes or songs. In some ways, this sounds like a Birds Of Fire track (which in itself is quite a feat), but to me it’s a little too close for comfort to appreciate this truly. After the relatively new-agey Remembering, the album closes on the 12-mins title track. Starting on a slow drone, the track remain gentle

Ratings only

  • JMLaFontaine
  • karolcia
  • blackbird
  • Vinyl Connection
  • lunarston
  • OJC86
  • Muerte Inoxia
  • wthii
  • Steve Wyzard
  • historian9
  • darkshade
  • timzurita
  • Drummer
  • rigoboy
  • richby

Write/edit review

You must be logged in to write or edit review

JMA TOP 5 Jazz ALBUMS

Rating by members, ranked by custom algorithm
Albums with 30 ratings and more
A Love Supreme Post Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
Kind of Blue Cool Jazz
MILES DAVIS
Buy this album from our partners
The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady Progressive Big Band
CHARLES MINGUS
Buy this album from our partners
Blue Train Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
My Favorite Things Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
JazzMusicArchives.com has always relied on banners ads to cover web hosting fees and all.

Please consider supporting us by giving monthly PayPal donations and help keep JMA fast-loading and ad-free forever.

New Jazz Artists

New Jazz Releases

Wanderer Vocal Jazz
SARAH PILLOW
Buy this album from MMA partners
Memory Bomb RnB
KIEFER
Buy this album from MMA partners
Fluidity Nu Jazz
NILS PETTER MOLVÆR
Buy this album from MMA partners
Paintbox Classic Fusion
EMMA RAWICZ
Buy this album from MMA partners
More new releases

New Jazz Online Videos

The First Circle
SARAH PILLOW
js· 6 hours ago
The Oak Tree
EMMA RAWICZ
js· 1 day ago
More videos

New JMA Jazz Forum Topics

More in the forums

New Site interactions

More...

Latest Jazz News

members-submitted

More in the forums

Social Media

Follow us