FunkFreak75
Recorded at Village Recorders, Los Angeles, Ca., on October 15, 16, 17, 1973 and then released by Milestone Records on May 21 of 1974.
A1. "Fire" (11:07) using a cool echo and reverb effect on the mic receiving Joe's tenor sax play, the rest of the band provides a steady (though sometimes overly repetitive without creating the saving benefit of being hypnotic) rhythmic weave. Michael White's violin solo in the sixth minute is wild but more, it's followed by a return to Joe's sax theme over which Alice Coltrane's harp stomps unceremoniously (who did the mixing of these tracks?) Once Joe gets the hint and backs out it's okay but Alice's harp always sounds as if it is recorded in another space and time--as if it was added way later or else started with and everything else was trying to build around her (I'm highly doubtful of this latter theory). Her playing is great, awesome, but it just doesn't fit: the rest of the band's weave feels muted and small in comparison, which is sad since they've been holding it together quite admirably for ten minutes! Bassist Charlie Haden gets some solo time in the tenth and eleventh minutes before piano and horns bring us back to the main theme. Some really cool ideas and sounds foiled by some rather poor sound mixing. (17.5/20) A2. "Air" (9:53) a foray into Free Jazz with Kenneth Nash, Alice Coltrane, Charlie Haden, and the band leader really going off each into their own universes. Michael White's violin joins in the mélée around the eight minute mark--which soon really pushes Joe and the others beyond any sense of the realms of melody. Luckily there is a fade-out-fade-in splicing in the final minute to bring the listener to an episode of peaceful cohesion for the song's conclusion. This must've been hell for engineer Rick Heenan and producer Orrin Keepnews to try to manage and make sense of. I understand the reasoning, I recognize the musicians' skilledness, I'm just not as much of a fan (yet) of the style (and outcome). (17.333/20)
B1. "Water" (7:33) layers of tamboura, harmonium, bells, sakara drum, stand alone bass notes and chords, heavily-treated saxophone (made to sound like an echoing Egyptian saz or the-like), and other percussion drums are exposed to the elements in an effort to create a sparse and foreign auditory experience (like being underwater?) In the sixth minute we are left with only the drone of the harmonium, the mesmerizing metronomic shake of a tambourine, and Charlie Haden's unusual syncopated bass sounds. Then Joe returns as well as background wooden flute and hand drums. Interesting, to say the least--and not annoying or cloyingly appropriational, truly original. Not my favorite music but I have to admit to being impressed for what the band pulled off. (13.25/15)
B2. "Earth" (13:15) opening with conga play before tamboura, sakara drum, and tabla set up a fecund foundational soil for Charlie, Ndugu, Joe, and, later, Michael White to enter in a coalition of downtempo funk for the establishment of a fairly rigid soul/R&B rhythm motif over which layers of Joe's saxophone and Kenneth's vast array of percussion instruments play for a few minutes. Then, around 4:30 everybody but the tamboura is faded out so that we can hear an extensive Charlie Haden solo. It's really cool how Charlie makes it sound/feel as if his bass is talking to itself in two separate voices--which also happen to sound like talking drums! In the seventh minute Joe's flute, Alice's glissing harp, and Kenneth's narration of what sounds now like some pretentious Beat-like poetry takes over for a couple minutes before the bass-and-drum funk motif returns for Michael's violin and Joe's tenor sax to dirge as if two keening women working both independently but performing at the same time and often merging/meshing harmonically. Interesting and, actually, pretty cool--that is, at least until Joe's sax pushes Michael out of the picture (to which the latter acquiesces). In the meantime Kenneth's fun in the play room continues as multiple percussion instruments get dusted off to make their temporary and often brief appearances in the mix--which is kind of good for the song in that it brings another interesting layer of counterpoint activity to the overall weave. (27.5/30)
Total Time: 41:41
Either engineer Rick Heenan or mix-master Skip Shimmin really messed up this album but it really comes down to the weak/poor oversight of producer Orrin Keepnews, doesn't it? I'm surprised band leader Henderson let it pass as is cuz there are some very fine performances of some pretty cool ideas expressed herein.
B/four stars; an album of very creative ideas and play that is hindered by the sound engineering/mixing/production. This really could have been a masterpiece of explorative First Wave Jazz-Rock Fusion!