FunkFreak75
Some critics and reviewers have denigrated this for being somewhat of a copy of Herbie's previous album, Takin' Off, but others, like me, have noted the slight expansion of Herbie's chops and compositional acumen. And these are all Herbie originals!
1. "Blind Man, Blind Man" (8:15) the upbeat, bluesy jazz tune plays like a familiar friend--this despite the unusual presence of Grant Green's jazz guitar. Trombonist Grachan Moncur III is a recent discovery of mine that I can't seem to get enough of (and there is not enough of hime on this song!) The main riff holding the song together gets a little old & monotonous despite several of the musicians attempts to spice it up with their increasingly lively accents. A lot of similarities in this song to Dave Brubeck/Paul Desmond's "Take Five." (17.5/20)
2. "A Tribute To Someone" (8:40) sublime "old-time" jazz beauty with very strong/excellent performances from Herbie, Chuck Israels, Hank Mobley, and especially Herbie's mentor, Donald Byrd. Solid, almost flawless. A lot like Isham Jones and Gus Kahn's 1924 classic, "It Had to Be You" (made most famous by Frank Sinatra). (18/20)
3. "King Cobra" (6:51) A monster of creative complexity, layers of it working together in brilliant harmonic weaves, also often working independently of one another in order to bring life to the whole entity. Herbie, Chuck, and Tony are amazing, Donald dependable as a rock, and I love the presence of trombone (I barely hear the guitar). Sounds very current with the kind of music Vince Guaraldi was doing at the same time. My favorite song on the album--and probably one of my favorite jazz tunes of the 1960s. (14.75/15)
4. "The Pleasure Is Mine" (4:00) great melodies on several layers of this brilliantly layered and harmonized weave. If this isn't jazz heaven--and compositional perfection--I don't know what is. Herbie's play, itself, is so smooth and patient, so mature-beyond his years--not unlike another piano phenom who appeared on the scene with a bang about seven years before (i.e. Bill Evans). (9.75/10)
5. "And What If I Don't" (6:30) a sassy, even culturally "non-white" song that cries out for more openly- Black representation in pop music. (8.875/10)
Total time 34:16
An album of eminently enjoyable, surprisingly sophisticated yet easily-accessible jazz compositions of a nostalgic type of classic "old" jazz pop.
A-/five stars; I have no hesitation to declare this wonderful collection of songs a minor masterpiece of jazz.