FunkFreak75
What a lineup! Talk about a who's who of Jazz-Rock Fusion! No wonder this album is such a landmark for so many people. The material that made it to the published album was recorded on December 12 and 13, 1972, at Van Gelder Studios and then released by CTI Records in January of 1973.
Line-up / Musicians: - Milt Jackson / vibraphone - Ron Carter / bass - Billy Cobham / drums - Freddie Hubbard / trumpet, flugelhorn - Jay Berliner / guitars - Ralph MacDonald / percussion - Herbie Hancock / piano With: - Don Sebesky / conductor - Phil Bodner / flute, piccolo, English horn - Romeo Penque / flute, oboe, English horn - George Marge / alto flute, clarinet, bass clarinet, English horn Violin – Charles Libove, David Nadien, Elliot Rosoff, Emanuel Green, Gene Orloff, Irving Spice, Joe Malin, Max Ellen, Paul Gershman Cello – Alan Shulman, Charles McCracken, George Ricci - Margaret Ross / harp
A1. "For Someone I Love" (10:08) the only composition on the album by Milt Jackson, it is set amongst a rich wind of orchestration and lead by trumpeter Freddie Hubbard as the band leader confidently fills space beneath him before launching into his own solo in the third minute (which is then usurped by Herbie Hancock's piano). I feel compelled to insert a special remark on Ron Carter's bass playing--which has become quite because it's been placed so unusually far forward (and given the loudest volume in the mix): he's amazing; it's as if he's soloing, really doing the most important leading on the song. In contrast, Billy Cobham's drums (which are also a marvel to behold) have been recorded quite unceremoniously as if Billy was relegated to the garage outside the studio while the microphones recording him are in the doorway! Weird! A good vehicle for Milt, Ron, Herbie, Freddie, and conductor Don Sebesky's orchestra; not so much for Billy Cobham. (Perhaps they didn't know how to handle the hot shot drummer's volume!) (17.75/20)
A2. "What Are You Doing The Rest Of Your Life?" (6:55) opening with a lush waves of orchestral swells, this makes me think that I'm being prepared for some great cinematic film event (the Alan & Marilyn Bergman/Michel Legrand song was, in fact, penned for the 1969 American film, The Happy Ending where it was sung by Michael Dees). There is an unmistakable similarity throughout this song to the music and melody lines of both the classic song, "Pure Imagination," from the 1971 film, Willy Wonka and The Chocolate Factory, as well as to those of Freddie's own masterpiece, "The Love Connection"--a song that the trumpeter would be working to polish and finalize over the course of the next seven years before it would take the perfected form of the title song on his 1979 album of the same name. What I love most about this song is how it is constructed with such care that none of the instruments are walking over the others: Milt and Freddie, Ron and Billy, Herbie and the orchestra, are all perfectly balanced, spaced, and blended to make for a beautiful, even emotional rendering of this under-appreciated song. (13.875/15)
B1. "People Make The World Go Round" (8:23) oddly enough, this is another one of those songs that trumpeter Freddie Hubbard latched onto/adopted and made his own--releasing his own version of it on his own 1975 studio album, Polar AC. He had been performing it live during 1972 with his own ensemble (which probably prompted him to bring it to this recording session). I can't say that I blame him: I had become a devoté of The Stylistics when they appeared on the music scene in 1971 with the a string of hit singles, starting with the March 1971 release of "Stop, Look, Listen (to Your Heart)" and then, in May, their first Top 10 hit, "You Are Everything," which became the band's first gold single. Both of these songs became features of the band's self-titled debut album when it was released in November, but it was "Betcha, Bye Golly, Wow" and "People" that really sealed my allegiance to the Philadelphia Soul act. Interestingly, I do feel that Freddie's version on Polar AC is considerably better than this one: this one is just too cluttered with Milt's Vibes and a bunch of other rag-tag instruments all vying for attention as if they can't decide who are the leads and what job the support musicians should be playing. Freddie, Milt, and Herbie trading leads at the beginning starts out okay but then everybody seems to take off each in their own direction as if the master of the Easter egg hunt has just said, "Go!" Then with Herbie in the lead and Milt answering the Fender Rhodes' call with his own responses it starts to unravel and loose direction and/or traction. Billy Cobham just doesn't sound into it, I don't even hear Jay Berliner or Ralph MacDonald, so they must've been napping. Only Ron Carter is truly in the pocket--and Freddie, when he's on point--which is only about 40 percent of the time. Perhaps they hadn't had enough rehearsal/practice time, but it's just not as good as it could've been (with this lineup!) The alternating punctuation marks of Freddie with Milt are kind of cool, but then Herbie (or somebody) takes a seat at a piano and tries playing the song as if he's the only one in the spotlight. Weird. (17.5/20)
B2. "Sunflower" (8:50) Freddie Hubbard must have either really loved this song or been very frustrated by it because I've found it on three studio albums on which he participated as well as countless live and "anthology/greatest hits" albums. The version here is nice, fairly true to Freddie's original vision, but the tandem recitation of the main melody by both Milt and Freddie, at the same time, are too much--each walking over one another: the harmonic effects of the trumpet feeling trampled upon by the broad spectrum chords of Milt's Vibraphone. The cool back-and-forth transitions into (and out of) the percussion jamming, slow ballad and up-tempo Latin, between Billy and Ralph that occurs here was not present on the 1966 Backlash original but is ramped up to perfection for the 1979 Love Connection version and done really well here, making this version a perfect medium between the two, representing, obviously, the work that Freddie's mind had put into the song's evolution. Here we have flutist Phil Bodner playing the flute but in a far reduced capacity than the essential role that James Spaulding had fulfilled on Backlash--Milt's Vibes taking the place of Spaulding's flute, whereas on the 1979 version there are no vibes with the flute being returned to the palette courtesy of Joe Farrell. I also love the work of both Herbie's understated Fender Rhodes electric piano and Margaret Ross' harp, both playing important roles in the background--until Herbie hops onto the piano bench for another solo in the fourth minute. Don Sebesky's orchestra strings begin to play a key role in the final two minutes, which actually works because the strings are used in spaces between lead instruments' phrases. All in all, this is a very good version with all parties and all elements of the sound palette performing on levels deserving of superlatives. (19/20)
Total time 41:59
A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of lushly-orchestrated Jazz-Rock Fusion that previews the Smooth Jazz that would ascend to the top of the commercially-viable Jazz music by the end of the decade.