FunkFreak75
Recorded by Manfred Eicher for ECM Records on July 23-24 1974 at Studio Bauer, Ludwigsburg. I'm excited to hear what two bass players and two guitarists will bring to Gary's sonosphere.
A1. "Mevlevia" (6:01) this one starts with a weave of gently-played instrumentalists sounding as if they're presenting some background music for one of Mr. Roger's skits with King Friday. At 0:50 it evolves into something a bit more sophisticated with some great interplay between Eberhard and Steve, between Gary and the two guitarists. Song composer Mick Goodrick's solo in the fourth minute is nice. (8.7510)
A2. "Unfinished Sympathy" (3:03) a rather monotonous weave that starts out with some energy and fire as if promising a Mahvishnu-like "Meeting of Spirits" event. It's just not the right instrumental palette despite Gary, Mick, and Bob's best attempts: they're just not loud and/or fiery enough! (8.875/10)
A3. "Tunnel Of Love" (5:30) after a long introductory period of slightly discordant arpeggio playing from everybody individually, it comes as a bit of a shock to see/hear that Eberhard is given the second solo: for the final two minutes! The first one is all Gary but his solo fits in so well with the weave of the other musicians that you barely discern or differentiate. I really appreciate and like the extra accent work effort put in by Bob: the only support instrument that feels alive. (8.75/10)
A4. "Intrude" (4:47) the only song without Eberhard and Mick; hearing that it's a nearly-five-minute drum solo makes this make sense. It is, interestingly, a very "elegant" drum solo: never trying to impress with power, speed, or super-syncopation. It's just smooth and . . . elegant! (9.125/10)
B1. "Silent Spring" (10:37) a rather droning, plodding foundation is given to Eberhard to solo over the minimalist support on this Carla Bley composition. His now-trademark "underwater bass" is on full display while Gary, Steve, Pat, and Mick robot-walk through the one-chord support accompaniment for seven minutes until the crew stops to watch the UFO in the distance hover and fade away for a minute. Then the two guitarists re-enter for a bit before backing out to allow Eberhard pure solo time. He is a fine bassist, even managing to find interesting melodies and interesting uses of his echoey space, but really the song is nothing to write home about. Gary and the crew return in a minimal capacity at 9:30 to take us home using Eberhard's melody and minimalist chord structure. (The best part of the song.) (17.375/20)
B2. "The Colours Of Chloë" (7:12) Eberhard's lone contribution to the album may, in fact, be its crowning achievement. (Gary must have thought as much as the composer himself had built an entire solo album around it in recording sessions that occurred in the same studio at the end of the previous year!) As reviewed for the The Colours of Chloë album (above), the song starts out like something from a Brian Eno Ambient Music album--until, that is, 1:15 when the rest of the band jumps in with the immediate establishment of a very nicely-woven sprint out of the tunnel-gate. Great two-chord structure propelled by some great melodies and driving drum play. But it only lasts for 30-seconds before ceasing its sprint, resting with Gary and the guitars arpeggiating gently before the two basses jump in with their dual-combined presentation of the bass melody. In the fourth minute everybody settles back into a very pleasant, vibrant and melodic whole-band weave over which Gary solos. His solo is so perfect! So masterful and never ostentatious or flamboyant. At 4:30 the basses reiterate their main melody before allowing guitarist to launch into a solo. Excellent! Another dual bass bridge at 6:15 to segue into a gentle, dreamy motif of disintegration to finish it off. Excellent rendition of an already great song! The main difference between this one and Eberhard's original is the role given to the guitarists to replace the keyboards and Eberhard's bass being doubled up and not being bowed in the first section. Also, I like Bob Moses' drumming much better than that of Ralf Hübner and the rich vibrato filler that Gary's vibraphone renders in place of Rainer Brüninghaus' piano. (14.5/15)
Total time: 37:10
I will commend band leader Burton for his composure and command: he leads with confidence and simplicity, needing no flare or panache to make his statements; he's just there, ubiquitous and detached to the competitive urges of his youthful collaborators. A great master and mentor. The fact of the compositional credits for three of the songs going to Gary's great friend and collaborator, conductor/composer Michael Gibbs helps explain the full-spectrum orchestra-like soundscapes achieved by the Quintet + one. (With six musicians contributing to every song but Bob Moses' solo drum tune, "Intrude," I'm not quite sure who exactly is in the "quintet.")
B+/4.5 stars; a near-masterpiece of exploratory Jazz-Rock Fusion that could've been better with a little more dynamic variety and enthusiasm on the front end. The cover of Eberhard's own composition, "The Colours of Spring," is, however, be worth the time and listen.