FunkFreak75
(The first disc of The Prime Element was re-released as a part of the At This Point in Time release in 1998).
Tracks A1 to B2 recorded at A&R Recording Studio, New York City, N.Y. on July 24, 25 & 26, 1973. Tracks C1 to D2 recorded at Rudy Van Gelder's, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey on March 14, 1969. All selections here were released for the first time by Blue Note sometime in 1976.
A1. "At This Point In Time" (7:35) an intense, hard-driving funk jazz cover of a tune offered by saxophonist Frank Foster that feels a little like something for orchestra and/or big band. Jan Hammer's Fender Rhodes is quite prominent as is each of the distinctive tracks of the horn section: flutes, soprano, tenor, and baritone saxes, trumpet as well as Warren Smith's timpani and Gene Perla's funk bass line. It has a laidback cockiness like the music of Herbie Hancock's Fat Albert Rotunda or Gil Scott-Heron's Pieces of a Man. (13.75/15)
A2. "Currents/Pollen" (11:16) another extraordinary solo drum intro--a full minute of just Elvin! In the second minute, while Elvin continues bashing away, the four percussionists join in, enriching the rhythmic weave with congas, wood block, it's not until 2:43 that anybody else joins in but when they do it's an immediate transformation into jazz with the bassist(s) fast-walking behind Jan Hammer's fast-paced soprano-sax-like MiniMoog soloing as Elvin settles into a smooth straightforward jazz accompaniment. In the fifth minute Elvin's accompanists desist while Elvin returns to bone-crushing skin-beating. In that fifth minute the horns enter as a horn section, presenting at first some low four-note chords but then gradually expanding the pitch spectrum until the middle of the sixth minute when there is a stoppage, bridge of chime sprinkles, followed by the start of an entirely new motif (this must be "Pollen")--this one sounding like something nice from The Soft Machine Third with a Latinized Deodato arrangement. Toward the end of the seventh minute Cornell Dupree steps into the spotlight with some jazz guitar, then Jan Hammer in the eighth with a Chick Corea-like Fender Rhodes solo. At the end of the ninth minute, when Jan Hammer steps back into a support role within the rhythm section, the horn section comes in with some cool sustain chords for about a minute until one of them (a tenor sax player, I think) steps forward to solo--holding this leadership position for the rest of the song--which ends up being a long, slow fadeout. I really liked everything about this incredibly odd song! I don't know how these two songs, one attributed to Don Garcia, the other to bassist Gene Perla, ended up being smashed together but I like it! I know I'll be returning to it for another dose! (19.25/20)
B1. "The Prime Element" (8:20) the kind of song and rhythms that makes you want to be there: just to watch the guys do this song. Latinized (look at all those percussionists employed to help out!) yet definitely exploring the J-R F palettes and textures. It is, therefore, no wonder that this song is attributed to percussionist Omar Clay as its chief composer. Jan Hammer is solid on his role as part of the rhythm section with his Fender Rhodes but then goes off with that MiniMoog like a Brasilian pole dancer! But the one message being sent from this music, from start to finish, is that Mr. Jones is a Boss of the Master class! An incredible listening experience if especially for Elvin's drumming. (18/20)
B2. "Whims Of Bal" (12:25) piano and xylophone are part of the whole-band ensemble presenting percussionist Omar Clay's second compositional contribution to this album. The opening sounds so avant-garde (even Zeuhlish) with its pounding dissonant chords--not unlike the Hermann Szobel album that cam out in this same month--but in the second minute the music settles into a nice faux-samba Latin-infused piano-based syncopated, percussion-aided vamp over which a baritone saxophone solos in its lower registers for about two minutes before being supplanted by a tenor sax for another couple of minutes before a soprano sax takes a turn. I like the piano work that's been going along beneath the reed instruments but I find myself (especially after the three previous songs) to not be hearing more dynamic adventuring from the rest of the rhythmatists. Around the nine minute mark there is a timpani-announced stoppage, which seems to serve as the faucet opening up a deluge of cacophonic free-jazz noise coming spilling out all over the floor until it has all spilled out and only sense and surprise are left to assess the outcome. Interesting finish! (22/25)
Disc One rating = 91.25
C1. "Inner Space" (6:34) here the band covers a Chick Corea composition using a big band arrangement for the horn section. The first of the recordings held since 1969, there is a notable "agedness" to the sound quality in the recording when compared to the other material from the first disc, which, again, were recorded in the Summer of 1973. Even the way the drum kit is recorded is quite different--with much more volume given to the cymbals and horns, far less to the low end (bass and toms) as well as a general "narrowness" to the overall soundscape. Also, Elvin's performance (as well as that of the whole ensemble) just feels much more circumscribed and conservative--as if the freedoms that Larry Coryell, The Mahavishnu Orchestra, and the Power Fusionists had unleashed were not even in the artists' realm of consideration yet (which, of course, they were not). It's good, solid hard bop but it has none of the animalistic testosterone that the other disc's songs all have. (8.75/10)
C2. "Once I Loved [O Amor Em Paz]" (6:18) the band's cover of an Antônio Carlos Jobim song: it is treated reverentially with some lovely flute playing the lead melodies in place of voice while Elvin, Ron, Candido Camero, and the other percussionists hold down the gentle rhythm track. Trumpeter Lee Morgan meanders around the sidelines with his muted horn until the two-minute mark when he stops allowing Joe Farrell to step up an octave with his flute in order to command full occupancy of the spotlight. At 3:40 the rolls are reversed as Joe silences his flute to let Lee step into the light tout seul. Nice--with nice solos--but nothing Earth-shattering here, just beauty. (8.75/10)
C3. "Raynay" (7:54) the first of Elvin's own compositional contributions to the album, it offers the listener some very interesting drum and percussion interactions steadied by a very smooth walking bass track as saxes and trumpet take turns soloing (while stepping into the line for horn section duties in-between solos). There are some nice solos as well as helpful horn section bridges while Elvin keeps provoking near-solo-like playfulness on his kit. The hot-shot drum playing doesn't work within the song weaves (or as stand alone entertainment) as well in 1969 as it does in 1973. (13.375/15)
D1. "Champagne Baby" (11:28) a song attributed to saxophonist Joe Farrell, it opens with a 30-second intro before seeming to find its groove, but then it suddenly returns to the wayward exploratory nature of the opening 30-seconds for a second go round of the "searching for a foothold" chord bursts before finally committing to the samba-percussed cymbal-happy motif that will play out for the bulk of the next ten minutes. (The rhythm track and odd beat signature sounds like it was lifted/borrowed/sampled and manipulated by 21st Century Swedish "romantic swingtronica" jazz band KOOP for their song, "In a Heartbeat.") Whoever the soloists are (I have to assume that Joe Farrell is one of them), they are really locked in and inspired--especially the sax soloists in the sixth and seventh minutes--which seems to inspire Elvin to some very creative drum play beneath him. At 7:45 everybody and his brother joins in, sounding as if they were each oblivious to one another, sealed into their own recording chambers with the rhythm track to listen to because they all seem to be spouting off with little or no regard for the other horn players. This loose cacophony, however, does not last long before the ensemble steps back to let Elvin do some of that inventive soloing that he does, only returning (with somewhat more arranged synchrony) to finish the song for the last minute. (17.875/20)
D2. "Dido Afrique" (11:16) Elvin's only other compositional credit, it is swinging and feeling very much like an example of some late 1960s television theme music--until it becomes all drums and percussion in the sixth minute. After nearly five minutes of this percussionist play the bass and horns return to try to reign the song back into its early themes but Elvin and his beat mates continues to exert their dominance, at times throwing the horns out of the mix, at the end allowing them to help finish. Interesting. (18/20)
Disc Two rating = 89.0
Total time: 83:06
I can't even begin to understand how and/or why Blue Note decided to release these two very different albums, recorded three and a half years apart, together as a single package--still three years after the second recording sessions had occurred. It makes perfect sense that someone with better sense would separate the two and re-release them years later as completely different packages. I, however, am cursed to have to rate this "album" as one single entity despite the overwhelming evidence that they are two completely different listening experiences. For any one reading this in the 21st Century, I urge you to seek out the 1998 Blue Note re-release of disc one as At This Point in Time and, if necessary, for completionists, the original The Prime Element release from 1976 in order to hear the 1969 material rendered unto disc two.
A-/4.5 stars (five stars for Disc One, a masterpiece of dynamic Jazz-Rock Fusion); an excellent snapshot into two different phases of Elvin's development.