COLOSSEUM/COLOSSEUM II — Valentyne Suite

Jazz music community with discographies, reviews and forums

COLOSSEUM/COLOSSEUM II - Valentyne Suite cover
4.21 | 12 ratings | 3 reviews
Buy this album from MMA partners

Album · 1969

Tracklist

A1 The Kettle
A2 Elegy
A3 Butty's Blues
A4 The Machine Demands A Sacrifice
The Valentyne Suite
B1a Theme One - January's Search
B1b Theme Two - February's Valentyne
B1c Theme Three - The Grass Is Always Greener...

Total Time: 35:29

Line-up/Musicians

Bass – Tony Reeves
Drums – Jon Hiseman
Guitar – James Litherland
Organ, Piano, Vibraphone, Mellotron – Dave Greenslade
Saxophone – Dick Heckstall-Smith

About this release

Vertigo ‎– VO 1(UK)

Recorded spring/summer 1969

Thanks to snobb for the updates



Buy COLOSSEUM/COLOSSEUM II - VALENTYNE SUITE music

COLOSSEUM/COLOSSEUM II VALENTYNE SUITE reviews

Specialists/collaborators reviews

No COLOSSEUM/COLOSSEUM IIVALENTYNE SUITE reviews posted by specialists/experts yet.

Members reviews

FunkFreak75
The energetic supergroup's second album release within the same calendar year. For Valentyne Suite they've lost contributing songwriter and guitarist John Roche, but they may be the better for it. With a lineup like this it would really be hard to go wrong!

1. "The Kettle" (4:25) opening with music that sounds like full-on guitar-centric power rock à la THE JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE, CREAM and BLIND FAITH. They even have two tracks dedicated to James Litherland's blazing guitar soloing as well as some very dynamic bass and drum playing. A powerful song--especially for an opener to a rock 'n' roll album--but not anything even close to resembling Jazz-Rock Fusion. (9.125/10)

2. "Elegy" (3:10) a very famous jazzy intro with the wah-wah-ed Hammond and iconic guitar chords. Great bluesy vocal from James Litherland. I can definitely see where bands like Canada's Lighthouse and The Jeff Beck Group got some of their inspiration. Great song. (9.5/10)

3. "Butty's Blues" (6:44) built over a classic blues chord progression, this song serves as a vehicle to put on display David Greenslade's prodigious Hammond organ skills as well as the introduction of Neil Ardley's awesome horn and orchestra arrangements. Another excellent vocal performance from James Litherland--one that doesn't even start until the very end of the second minute--makes me wonder why this guy isn't mentioned along with the greatest blues rock singers of all-time. I'm not a huge fan of classic blues but this rock- and orchestra-embellished tune is stunning! Some great sax play from Dick Heckstall-Smith. (9.25/10)

4. "The Machine Demands a Sacrifice" (3:52) another blues-rocker that sports a raspier and background vocal supported vocal from, I'm assuming, James Litherland. (His voice on this one almost sounds blown--at the end of its capacity.) I hear no drum machine, just machine-like drumming. (8.75/10)

5. "The Valentyne Suite" (16:51) an ambitious song with solid compositional goals but lacking a little of the skills necessary to pull it off as well as they designed it. (31.125/35) - "Theme One: January's Search" (6:25) the dramatic opening pays homage to both THE NICE and PROCOL HARUM as well as previews the heights aimed for by Keith Emerson with his "Tarkus" and "Karn Evil" suites. The biggest difference here is the amazing contributions of Dick Heckstall and Barbara Thompson's horns here delivered through the use of multiple tracks. At 3:20 we enter into a new motif via Dave Greenslade's solo Hammond organ--resulting in a bluesy rockabilly sound as Dave solos and the others support. (The drums here sound a little out of place.) I like all the pitch-shifting Dave is fooling around with on his organ but this is not my favorite type of music. But, that opening half was amazing. (9/10) - "Theme Two: February's Valentyne" (3:33) wordless choir vocals and sax support a slowed down PROCOL HARUM-like passage. The support musicians slowly ramp up their contributions as Dick Heckstall-Smith gets deeper into his sax solo: the Hammond and bass in particular. However, Jon Hiseman's drumming, again, feels a little weak. (8.75/10) - "Theme Three: The Grass Is Always Greener" (6:55) back to blues rock for some spotlighting of bassist Tony Reeves and the guitar playing of James Litherland. (He's good but, in my opinion, a much better singer than guitarist.) Finally Jon Hiseman's drumming fits--his skills show. (13.375/15)

Total Time 35:02

Not an album that I'm willing to attach the "Jazz-Rock Fusion" moniker to--even despite the jazzy-ness of the Side Two-long "Valentyne Suite." Though I revere the drumming of Jon Hiseman, he has not yet, by this album, reached the peak of his skills and talents, whereas the rest of the band seems to really be at the top of their creative instincts. And, again, why singer James Litherland isn't among the list of iconic vocalists from this era is a mystery to me. Perhaps if he'd have had a voice in the Suite it could have been even more powerful.

A-/five stars; a wonderful album of ambitious song rendering whose performance results almost reach the heights of the band's compositional visions. This is no Jazz-Rock Fusion but it definitely qualifies as an early or prototype for all future progressive rock music.

Sean Trane
Second article in series of five.

Second album from this groundbreaking quintet that had offered us much of a thrill with their debut. Again here, if you are looking for the vinyl, please be aware that this album came out with a very close-looking version in America, but a completely different track list and is titled, The Grass Is Greener 5BTW, I distinctly remember a first version of Lost Angeles on this version of the album). Again here I will review the Cd version as to not complicate things uselessly. What one must realize is that this album was the first released by progressive label Vertigo and the first vinyl to have that superb spiral spinning around the vortex of the record. A real delight to watch it spinning especially while listening to the second side of the vinyl. As if that label and that track were made for each other.

Starting in the same fashion as their debut on an incredibly positive, joyously-communicative (bordering on the epidemic contagion ;-), with Litherland stealing the show both with his superb voice and his wild guitar wailings, James “Butty” is reaching his moment of glory in this RnB-infested rock track. A real gas even if you are not that much in RnB music. Elegy has absolutely nothing to envy its predecessor both in happiness but here DH-S’s sax takes the centre-stage and the group is accompanied by a superb string section, which at times draws chills in your back. As you might have guessed, the next track is a rather slow blues with an infectious organ groove and heavy brass section, and Butty Litherland unleashing his heart onto an unsuspecting microphone and your disbelieving here. Orgasmic. Closing of the A-side is a much-more Sacrifice-Demanding Machine, which confirms the progressive qualities detected in the debut album, even if the tracks is also starting as a blues, but this time much more oppressive than previous tracks and it has mid-track fade out (well this is not yet the 70’s, so one can forgive the less successful experimentations such as this one. The track ends in a total chaos, which still shows that ideas were there, but not always perfectly laid out on wax.

But all you progheads are giving a hoot about is my coming down to describing the chef d’oeuvre that is coming out and filling (and fulfilling you) the B-side. Starting out a bit like Bernstein’s Blue Rondo a La Turc (or more like The Nice’s version of it), the track soon diverges from it as Greeenslade’s delicious vibraphone descending lines reach directly into your heart, blocks the main vein and all you have to do is wait for the vibes to return before the strokes gets to you. But Dave is a gentleman and happily obliges some more life-saving orgasmic vibes lines. Clearly, this track is Greenslade’s “Heure De Gloire”, the track he will forever remembered for and as the first movement ends with him having switched to piano (McCoy Tyner-influenced) with DH-S approaching the feel of this writer’s ultimate musician, John Coltrane during A Love Supreme!!!!!! Needless to say that Hiseman was playing along as if he was Elvin Jones. 30 years down the road this passage still nails me to the floor with tears of joy flowing out uncontrollably. The main Brubeck-inspired theme then takes over again with Greenslade now taking more liberties with the harmonies, while the track is only made possible by Hiseman’s wild drumming. As the track is again calming down, Butty Litherland comes in along with the others for some superb angelic vocalizing superbly underlined by D H-S’s sax lines. To say that much of this track was written on the day that mankind walked on the moon (although only 6 at the time, I remember that day vividly) is simply so telling, July 21st 69!!! The third part is letting more part to the guitar, but Greenslade is dominating the debate again, and there are some incredibly delightful exchanges between the two but DHS is never far away either. Clearly, TVS is taking off where The Ides Of March had left it on the debut album. But as orgasmic this track is, there is also a feel that the many influences it draws from, even if well-digested are a bit too obvious and this might just be the ultimate reason why Colosseum will never break the big leagues like Yes or Crimson.

Unfortunately for him Litherland was to be sacked because he was mostly a blues player, and Hiseman being the boss he was (the group’s official name is John Hiseman’s Closseum), and having the opportunity to snatch Clempson from Bakerloo. Tony Reeves left also on musical grounds but of his own. So Clempson will bring in Mark Clarke into the band also. This second album while still not completely progressive, is certainly as historically important as The Nice’s debut or Crimson’s ITCOTCK and just for that merits the fifth star. Awesome!!!

There is an expanded edition of the album that presents this present album with two bonus BBC tracks (from a John Peel show) and on the second disc the album The Grass Is Greener (please see the separate entry for my review on that one). The two BBC tracks are of excellent quality: Albert’s Moustache is a rare Tony Reeves track, which includes (would you believe it?) an extended bass solo, the songwriting being weak enough to serve as vehicle for the bass doodling. Next is yet another version of the Lost Angeles track, sung with Clempson at the mike no worse (I don’t like Clem’s singing) than the one on TGIG. If it wasn’t for that second disc, the upgrade wouldn’t be worth it for those two tracks alone.

AtomicCrimsonRush
Inspired Early Prog - But Nowhere Near Masterpiece Quality.

This is a breakthrough album certainly not only for Colosseum but for prog rock, and jazz. This album features all the proggish elements: the side long epic 'The Valentyne Suite' (absolute brilliance), the thematic proggy 'The Machine Demands A Sacrifice ' and the ultra riff heavy 'The Kettle ' (my favourite). This in itself is deserving of a high star rating.

However there are a few rather dull moments for the rest of the CD and this marrs the rating considerably as it is so inconsistent. The extra bonus tracks and second version of the disc have some excellent moments too such as 'JUMPING OFF THE SUN' but the rest is all rather forgettable unfortunately.

I saw this eye catching CD and grabbed it eagerly expecting a masterpiece in light of how much people rave about this album. Instead I was thrown off balance at how ordinary a lot of it is. Perhaps it was ahead of its time and the band did not seem to know which direction they were heading. Jazz fusion, heavy rock riffs, orchestrations and even blues, but all as inconsistent as these genres themselves. There are notably 4 great tracks but they are set amidst a wash of forgettable tunes. It still is worth getting hold of for the aforementioned tracks but ultimately it is not as great as many will have you believe. 3 and a half stars for the innovative music.

Ratings only

  • Jack Revelino
  • stefanbedna
  • Phrank
  • KK58
  • Lynx33
  • EntertheLemming
  • Ponker
  • joe
  • TALIESYN

Write/edit review

You must be logged in to write or edit review

JMA TOP 5 Jazz ALBUMS

Rating by members, ranked by custom algorithm
Albums with 30 ratings and more
A Love Supreme Post Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
Kind of Blue Cool Jazz
MILES DAVIS
Buy this album from our partners
The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady Progressive Big Band
CHARLES MINGUS
Buy this album from our partners
Blue Train Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
My Favorite Things Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
JazzMusicArchives.com has always relied on banners ads to cover web hosting fees and all.

Please consider supporting us by giving monthly PayPal donations and help keep JMA fast-loading and ad-free forever.

New Jazz Artists

New Jazz Releases

Wanderer Vocal Jazz
SARAH PILLOW
Buy this album from MMA partners
Memory Bomb RnB
KIEFER
Buy this album from MMA partners
Fluidity Nu Jazz
NILS PETTER MOLVÆR
Buy this album from MMA partners
Paintbox Classic Fusion
EMMA RAWICZ
Buy this album from MMA partners
More new releases

New Jazz Online Videos

The First Circle
SARAH PILLOW
js· 9 hours ago
The Oak Tree
EMMA RAWICZ
js· 1 day ago
More videos

New JMA Jazz Forum Topics

More in the forums

New Site interactions

More...

Latest Jazz News

members-submitted

More in the forums

Social Media

Follow us