Emerson Lake and Palmer First Album 1970
1. The Barbarian 2. Take a Pebble 3. Knife-Edge 4. The Three Fates 5. Tank 6. Lucky Man
Keith Emerson - Keyboards Carl Palmer - Drums and Percussion Greg Lake - Guitars It's 2025. I have heard this many times before, but never wrote much about it.
Listening to it today, this is astonishing, and a fantastic example of what the ideas were about extending music to an artistic level that had a chance to get played in America on the FM radio band, and appreciated like it couldn't in the other radio band of hits.
So, hearing the opening, "The Barbarian" ... all of a sudden you can see how formulaic the majority of music that you hear these days, as shown in many places with suggestions that are "similar" as opposed to the opposite. Similar to saying some folks have no music appreciation senses at all, and have to hear things that are similar in order to be attuned to some of the music ... and this has been the main issue with "progressive music" and specially "prog rock" for the past 25 or so years, when all you hear is similar sounding and the music breaks in exactly the same parts, and the solos are always in the same place. It's not about the music ... it's about the sound and the idea, and someone telling you how good, or important the piece is, and in the end, it is just another commercially sounding piece. And talent has become defined by the 3 or 4 chords that you hear, not the music.
So, as much as I have loved this band a lot and appreciated their classical over tones, the emptiness that you find when you get done listening to this album and then put on something else, is monstrous ... and something that you remember, even though it is likely that you are not going to humm it along, like you can with the big hit song in this album, that even had a trimmed down version for a single so the hit stations could also play it, but sadly, that song while exceptional, is not the fantastic composition that the rest of the album gives you ... and describing it is a bit on the weird side as many folks will hear different things ... and just like seeing this band listed on JMA ... is one incredible thing ... is it classical? is it jazz? is it rock? what is it?
I venture to say, mostly, that this band is classically minded, though many folks get upset with the fun bits and pieces that some of their albums have, which might not be exactly as strong musically as they are fun, and probably provided the band with a break during their concerts, with material that is so tough that most folks won't even try it, and in the end, it has been orchestral versions of their work that are mostly appreciated, if not the various acoustic versions of things that Rachel Flowers has done, which sends this band's music into another stratosphere of experience.
Many folks think of this is progressive and experimental ... and I have taken a very different idea and task ... if you were a graduate student and brought a score for "The Barbarian" or "Take a Pebble" or the best example "Tarkus" (different album) it would not be considered by many professors as valuable or important, for a variety of reasons, and it really wasn't until a few years back when Rachel Flowers did a solo piano version of TARKUS in its entirety that you realize the impossible ... it was a Piano Concerto, but in 1970, no professor was going to give you an A for the effort at all ... but with all the different sounds and combinations of organ and synthesizers, the piece comes alive differently, though it is much better appreciated as a solo piano piece ... and at the time, classical music was starting to take a leap off the pier into the ocean of nothing ... sales of classical music disappeared, and no one was going to bother ... with "new music" of a classical nature, but presented with the tools of the time and place, changes everything. And we fell for it, hook, line and sinker ... not to mention that you will remember what you heard, however different and weird it might be considered ... it is primeval and excellent, in a way, that is still not found today ... where the majority of folks play loud and louder, with little compositional design other than a format for their solo and placement, and the usual "lyrics" to tell the audience what it is all about ... and this was a knock in the first days of this album ... no lyrics? How do we know what it is all about? And many folks drop out ... music is weird and it don't tell us nothing! I like to joke that for 600 years all composers were idiots ... thinking that people could create visuals off the music itself! What a joke that would be in Mozart's time, when you see a bit from a film of his way of composing things, and Salieri going ... what? ... how ... that doesn't ... but he went along with it because he knew something was there ... very different, and it gave music a new direction and touch that most didn't get, as evidenced in the film by the court and king as a bunch of buffoons. Keith Emerson would have loved the "too many notes" comment, and given them a headache!
After "The Barbarian", you will get to see the classical music first hand, and it comes alive in "Take a Pebble", "Knife-Edge" and the "The Three Fates" and it is a signal of things to come that is hard to imagine in their next albums. It is, in essence a lot of modern classical music done in the area of rock music or at least youngsters that had the talent and ability but told classical folks to take a flying fig ... the appreciation for music was determined by your ability to play this or that ... not what you just created, because the professors won't listen to it, as it doesn't sound like the modern stuff they use to "define" what music is, and the idea of popular music, or rock music, making a dent in the classical elements is a joke, or a badly mixed drink. But when you hear so much of this band's material done by orchestras these days, it's not difficult to enjoy it and appreciate the incredible music and its design, for the sake of an audience, which also worked, and better than we can imagine.
Believe it or not this is a difficult album to listen to. You can not get attached to anything since there is so much and so different in 5 pieces in the album ... excepting the "hit song" in its incredible glory. I wonder how "Lucky Man" would have sounded with Robert Fripp on the guitar ... but we will never know ... and without a doubt one of the greatest albums of the so-called "progressive music" era.