snobb
Pianist Simon Nabatov’s very intimate, monumental new double CD album contains two of his composed suites; he plays piano on both as well, among others. Very unusually, I started reading the liner notes before listening to the music, and... didn't click the "play" button after I finished all the text. I am not an emotional person, but what I read shocked me. Not because I found something I had never heard before, but because the story told was very close to me and familiar. I left the album alone without even starting to listen to it; after some time, I just read the text once again.
I started listening to the musical content the next day only when I was ready. The music caught me strongly as well.
Simon Nabatov, a musician of Jewish descent, was born in Moscow, the capital of the former Soviet Union - the heart of the bloody Evil Empire - in 1959. His grandfather was a high-level officer in the central KGB (then known as NKVD) structures, living in a 12-room flat in the centre of Moscow. Probably responsible for thousands of deaths of his own people. Owning a mini-Zoo in one of the rooms, with exotic birds and animals, for his daughter. And he loved race cars too.
Semyon Jakowlewitch Mindal (Simon Nabatov has been named in his memory) was arrested, tortured, and liquidated as part of Stalin’s purges when his daughter, Nabatov's mother, was 12. Simon's family in 1979 were permitted to leave the USSR for Israel, as Jewish expatriates, but instead flew to Italy and applied for visas to enter the United States. Nabatov studied at Juilliard School from 1980 to 1984 and became an American citizen in 1986. From 1989, he has lived in Europe, mostly in Cologne.
I was born in the same Soviet Empire, just five years later than Simon. Not in Moscow, though. I was born in Vilnius - one of the most culturally rich and beautiful European cities, occupied by russians and incorporated into their Empire at the end of WWII. My biological grandfather died on the military campaign at the very beginning of WWII, leaving my grandmother with an 8 year old daughter on her hands. Grandmother, who was always a boss in our family, soon married a high-ranking KGB officer, responsible for the city's railways. According to the family legend, in 1946 he died quickly and unexpectedly, because of "too humid climate". A professional KGB officer in his late thirties? Do you believe? Simply, "Stalin's cleansing" words sounded too terrible to be told, even in a family. And I never heard anything or saw his grave in my life either. Being old, my grandmother told a few times that "they had a great time during the war - with regular balls, drinking champagne and eating caviar". After her husband's death, she - wife of a high-position KGB officer - found herself staying right on the street with a teenage daughter, with no place to live, no job and no money. She survived again; her new boyfriend, who later taught me to read and to write, was a former marine, taken prisoner by Nazis in 1941, who spent the rest of the war in a military prisoner camp in Cologne. I remember, as a teenager, more than once, him shouting on public transport that “the best time of his life was when in a German prisoner camp”. He didn’t succeed in his career in the Soviet Union, that’s for sure.
Album's second suite, completing all of CD 2, is titled "What my grandfather could tell me", and dedicated to Nabatov's grandfather. Each of eight songs has the author's comments presented in liner notes, in fact, a little story.
The album's first suite, "Your ID Please", takes all of CD 1 and is dedicated to Simon's childhood and formation period, full of drama and tension. In the same way as the second suite, each composition of the first suite is supported with short comments in the liner notes. Simple stories which weren't so easily told, I expect. Nabatov tells how his father brought him to the synagogue, and about "being amazed by the „otherness“ of what was supposed to be part of me (but wasn’t really)." On the other hand, young Simon finds spiritual support (I would call it - the escape from Soviet reality) in the Russian Orthodox church. He says: "It was a beautiful world, full of grace and mystery. Even though it was supposed to be completely foreign to Jewish life, it influenced me a lot, in more ways than I am able to detect."
There were no Jews in my family, but I was born and grew up in a city, for ages known as "Northern Jerusalem". I spent the very first years of my life in a former Jewish Quarter, where we lived with my grandparents and mother. Some buildings were still abandoned; from the hundreds of thousands of former Jews, there were left fewer than five thousand there. Others disappeared during the Nazi's occupation and the Holocaust, were killed, or left and never returned. Our nearest neighbors and friends were Jewish families, those who survived. My grandmother spent evenings speaking with "aunt Rachile"; her teenage daughter Rivka taught me the very first steps in my life on the green hill nearby. The house we lived in was just a ten-minute walk from a synagogue, the only one that survived, from sixty, being in town before WWII. I have never visited it, though.
My grandmother, christened in an Orthodox church as a child, never visited it. But she often took me to Catholic churches, a beautiful Baroque world full of light, paintings, and organ music. I have never been religious, but often visit Catholic churches around the world - as monuments of art and beauty. Dark and mysterious Orthodox churches (I have visited plenty of them around the world too) always make me feel uncomfortable. I feel like they try to delete my personality, make me feel helpless and dependent, and scared. I never give up.
The reason I wrote such a long intro (”the story inside of the story”) is that I just want to illustrate how important a background of knowledge is sometimes for the appreciation of one or another musical work. I am sure that only a listener familiar with the time, place, and atmosphere of Nabatov's stories can appreciate his two new suites in full depth. That’s why I highly recommend starting with reading the liner notes, and in case of interest, continuing with deeper research on the epoch. On the other hand, the music presented here is so strong in itself that it can attract the unprepared listener too, I believe. Even if Nabatov and I will probably agree in some assessments, and disagree in others, without doubt I understand his every note and sound much deeper than the listener, less familiar with the background.
So, now about the music itself in more detail. Each suite is recorded in a single day in 2024, with two combos of highly skilled musicians. “Your ID Please” is recorded by a septet, containing, alongside Nabatov on piano, a chamber strings trio (Axel Lindner - violin, Axel Porath - viola, Nathan Bontrager - cello), renowned German reedist Frank Gratkowski, oboist Ina Stock, and Lucia Mense on recorders. “What my grandfather could tell me” is recorded by a quite different quintet with a strings duo(Axel Porath - viola, Nathan Bontrager - cello), Pascal Klewer on trumpet, Shannon Barnett on trombone, a rhythm section(Roger Kintopf on bass, Alex Parzhuber on drums) alongside Nabatov on piano himself, and another German jazz star - Polish-born sax player Angelika Niescier. No matter the instrumentation, both suites present an organic mix of(dominating) 20th-century classical music, Russian and Jewish folk, Orthodox church chants, Soviet pop tunes, and jazz improvs. The description sounds chaotic on paper, but in real life all compositions are surprisingly well organized, often quite ascetic. The elements of different genres are often presented in the same composition; they change seamlessly, without destroying the clear structural line. Many compositions, besides the author’s comments on thematic content, contain brief comments on musical instrumentation and arrangements, which help to appreciate the music better. Never overcrowded, both suites’ music builds a very special, near-sanctuary atmosphere, full of drama and relief at the same time. In fact, it is very close to Orthodox chants, in the way it works.
Very intimate and unique work; it invites you to experience an emotional catharsis together.