Matti P
Roberta Flack (1937 - 2025) was a classically trained pianist already as a teenager, but she entered the field of popular music in the late 60's. Her debut album First Take (1969), "an elegant fusion of folk, jazz and soul", wasn't an instant success, nor was Chapter Two (1970). Her popularity started escalating when Clint Eastwood used the debut album's lovely Ewan McColl cover 'The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face' in his directorial debut Play Misty for Me (1971). Released as a single, the song spent six weeks at No. 1 in 1972.
Killing Me Softly was her fourth album, excluding the duet work Roberta Flack & Donny Hathaway (1972). 'Killing Me Softly With His Song' was Flack's second number one hit, a Charles Fox composition to the Don McLean inspired lyrics by Norman Gimbel. Roberta Flack heard Lori Lieberman's original version on an airplane and was immediately charmed. The following album also was a major success, reaching placements two (soul LP's) and three (Billboard).
The a cappella intro of 'Killing Me...' has a spiritual touch which isn't entirely lost in the soft, r&b oriented arrangement either. Flack plays electric piano in it. She didn't contribute as a writer on any of the eight tracks. The second song 'Jesse' is an extremely tender and slow-tempo Janis Ian cover dedicated to the civil rights activist Jesse Jackson. 'No Tears (In the End)' was written by Ralph MacDonald who plays percussion on the album. This is a more lively soul song featuring a brass arrangement and a background choir.
'I'm the Girl' (written by bluegrass guitarist James Alan Shelton) is charming in its romantic serenity, backed only by Flack's piano and Kermit Moore's cello. A certain highlight for me. 'River', not to be confused with the Joni Mitchell song, is a gospel/soul piece reminiscent of Aretha Franklin. Personally I'm not fond of either of the two uptempo songs this far. 'Conversation Love' is beautiful both as an elegant composition and as an arrangement featuring strings and wind instruments.
'When You Smile', another MacDonald composition, is a joyful and sunny piece with horns, strong rhythm and a saloon-like piano. A bit too merry for my taste. The album closes with an excellent Leonard Cohen cover 'Suzanne'. Flack's dreamy version has a nuanced, jazzy and dynamically growing arrangement that lifts it among the best performances of this heavily covered classic. All in all this album itself has become a classic. Despite not really liking the three non-soft songs I can stretch my rating to four stars. The production and sound are of high quality.