js
Continuing the series of reviews of current bands that play 1920s “hot jazz”, we come to Andrew Oliver and Hal Smith’s Incomparables and their new album, “Stomp Your Stuff”, which attempts to re-create the music of Jelly Roll Morton’s Red Hot Peppers. As mentioned in previous reviews, the make or break for bands that try to play in a 1920s style is whether or not they are bringing the kind of manic and chaotic energy to the music that made this music the choice sound for outlaws and party fiends back in the day. To their credit, the Incomparables do bring the noise, much like fellow current hot jazzers like The Joymakers and Terry Waldo’s Gotham City Band. A look at the musician credits on “Stomp Your Stuff” reveals Colin Hancock on cornet and alto sax, Colin is the leader of the Joymakers and also works with Terry Waldo’s band. Having the energetic and rambunctious Colin on board is always a good sign.
The Incomparables are co-led by pianist Oliver Smith, an expert on ragtime and stride piano, as well as the piano playing of Jelly Roll Morton, and drummer Hal Smith, well known for his expertise in early jazz. From the Incomparables press kit: “The ensemble does far more than recreate vintage recordings, instead, the group re-imagines obscure and long overlooked material from the Melrose Brother’s publishing catalog through the arranging concepts, rhythmic architecture and tightly woven ensemble exchanges Morton pioneered during his landmark 1926-27 Red Hot Peppers sessions”. In other words, the Incomparables have used their knowledge of the Jelly Roll Morton approach to record these songs as they might have sounded if recorded by the Red Hot Peppers.
Along with the manic ‘reefer madness’ energy, the arrangements in this music are constantly morphing with stop on a dime changeups and an ADD approach to musical ideas. Fast changing arrangements like this will disappear from the music world during the more laid back swing era and really don’t come back until the arrival of certain early 70s art rock bands like Gentle Giant and Frank Zappa. As we approached the new century, the modern jazz world again embraced the idea of complicated arrangements, and although today’s cutting edge jazz does not sound like the 1920s, there is some similarities in approach. Almost every track on this album is instrumental, which is nice, sometimes the vocal tracks on 1920s jazz can be a little too cute or they can come across as attempts at pop crossover.