FRANK ZAPPA — Joe's Grage Acts I, II & III

Jazz music community with review and forums

FRANK ZAPPA - Joe's Grage Acts I, II & III cover
2.09 | 10 ratings | 2 reviews
Buy this album from MMA partners

Boxset / Compilation · 1987

Tracklist

Disc one
1. The Central Scrutinizer (3:28)
2. Joe's Garage (6:10)
3. Catholic Girls (4:26)
4. Crew Slut (6:31)
5. Fembot In A Wet T-Shirt (4:45)
6. On The Bus (4:19)
7. Why Does It Hurt When I Pee? (2:36)
8. Lucille Has Messed My Mind Up (5:43)
9. Scrutinizer Postlude (1:35)
10. A Token Of My Extreme (5:30)
11. Stick It Out (4:34)
12. Sy Borg (8:56)

Disc two
1. Dong Work For Yuda (5:03)
2. Keep It Greasey (8:22)
3. Outside Now (5:50)
4. He Used to Cut the Grass (8:35)
5. Packard Goose (11:34)
6. Watermelon In Easter Hay (9:09)
7. A Little Green Rosetta (8:15)

Total Time: 115:21

Line-up/Musicians

- Frank Zappa / guitar, arranger, conductor, vocals, producer
- Ed Mann / percussion, vocals
- Ike Willis / vocals
- Dale Bozzio / vocals
- Arthur Barrow / bass, vocals
- Marginal Chagrin / sax (Baritone)
- Vinnie Colaiuta / drums
- Warren Cuccurullo / guitar, guitar (rhythm), vocals
- Jeff / sax (Tenor)
- Al Malkin / vocals
- Tommy Mars / keyboards
- Patrick O'Hearn / bass
- Craig Steward / harmonica
- Stumuk / sax (Baritone), sax
- Denny Walley / vocals, slide guitar
- Peter Wolf / keyboards

About this release

Barking Pumpkin Records (US), Rykodisc (US)

Thanks to EntertheLemming for the addition and snobb for the updates

Buy FRANK ZAPPA - II & III JOE'S GRAGE ACTS I music

More places to buy metal & FRANK ZAPPA music

  • CDUniverse - Specializing in the sale of domestic and imported music CDs and Imports

FRANK ZAPPA II & III JOE'S GRAGE ACTS I reviews

Specialists/collaborators reviews

EntertheLemming
Beached Harpoonist Claims Bullied by Whales

I felt secure in the knowledge that the worst concept album ever made by anyone, anywhere was 'Preservation Acts I & II' by the Kinks. This was a flimsy edifice of twee Orwellian drivel from a band I considered to be one of my favourites of all time.(and still do) Ray Davies' tale of a huge faceless corporation (read EVIL) that wished nothing more than to drive out ordinary people (read GOOD) from their humble villages (read GOOD) in the pursuit of mercenary gain, (read EVIL) for all its overreaching artifice and risible bravado, was at the very least sincere but grievously misguided.

'Joe's Garage' is much, much worse. Let me sum up the plot for you:

Rock'n'Roll is dumb and its practitioners often smell bad (yet somehow the prurient obsessions of hirsute guitar totin' plankton are our only hope of salvation from those who wish to stifle such sedition) Rock stars are the waay coolest enemies of the state as their music is subversive, dangerous and thus a threat to the pillars of convention.

Blow it out yer denim clad wazoo Frank, this document is all the proof needed that like charity, censorship begins at home. Had just one of his expensively assembled sessioneer luvvies had the cojones to advise Frank this whole disingenuous farce was a locker room summit, things may have turned out differently.

Circa 1979 in Zappa's post modern but pre Kinsey Report psyche, America 'hid' sex because it was 'dirty' and disapproved of 'Rawk' because it was the 'devil's music' and promoted 'carnal thoughts' ergo, he had a mandate to throw double entendres, blow-jobs, wet t-shirts, titties, beer and whatever other rotten fruit from his abandoned orchard at a prudish and blushing suburbia. In the soiled realm of the scatological (a non-sequitur to be sure) you get the overriding impression that toilet training must have been delivered by pets to their owners. The only individual or member of a demographic referenced in this album who actually has an undeniable hang up about sex, is Frank Zappa. In this cramped and humid FZ cosmology there are basically two types of female: Groupies and women who 'really' want to be groupies despite their protestations to the contrary.

As to what heavyweight chopmeisters such as Vinnie Colaiuta, Tommy Mars and Terry Bozzio were doing replicating the efforts of a bar band fuelled by Dutch Courage on many of these tracks is beyond me. If the Beatles White Album can be considered an affectionate and skilful homage to a wide variety of popular music styles, then Joe's Garage is its corollary: a spiteful and lazy parody of those styles that serves only to accentuate whatever vestige of merit remains in what is being ridiculed. One of the pifalls/benefits (you choose) inherent in lampooning musical genres is that your audience, if dumb or gauche enough, actually start to mistake your deceit for the genuine article. Zappa is certainly no lard-head but I'm sure that at this point from his embittered leer he would have derived great relish in passing off vinegar as Honky Château for under-age drinkers. All manner of scribbled approximations of what crass and venal popular culture represents are attempted here: parochial world music, booty motionless disco, Goths tackling funk, cartoon racism 'wops' doo-wop, farm-boy industrial, Not In My Back Yardies Reggae, debonair wino crooners and bogus boogie all merely serve to show Zappa's resentment that he couldn't write a single good pop song during his entire career. (It's harder than it looks Frankie snicker)

Many apologists for this archly conservative 'panto for longhairs' have cited Zappa's avowed inspiration sourced from the extant Iranian revolution. That someone might identify Islamic Sharia law, separation of the sexes, guardianship of the jurist and the veiling of females as representative of inalienable freedoms preferable to the brutal and violent imposition of western values can of course be debated at length, but FZ is clearly befuddled by a choice between the land of his birth propping up a dictatorial regime or replacing same with an equally repellent alternative.

It shouldn't come as any surprise that musicians as routinely accomplished as those gathered here cannot be unremittingly wretched for a whole 2 hours and there are a couple tracks on 'Joe's Garage' that escape the prevailing puerile gigglefest:

'Watermelon in Easter Hay' is an exquisitely beautiful guitar solo that boasts a tone and timbre unmatched in the entire FZ oeuvre. Over a sparing and largo 9/4 groove Frank weaves and flexes sinews of controlled power and lyricism all too often neglected in his vast arsenal of admirable chops. Wet T Shirt Night would have made a decent instrumental but isn't so erm...

If you're 14 years old, (biologically or otherwise) live close to Lake Clearasil and giggle at the words 'Moby Dick' or 'crevice' then this is your holy grail.

Members reviews

Warthur
I'll stick my review of this here as opposed to under the individual album entries since really they all form one single piece. Joe's Garage is an epic narrative concept album by Zappa in which Zappa really doesn't show that much interest in maintaining a narrative but goes about shoehorning one in anyway in as irritating a way as possible.

Don't get me wrong - there's some fun material on here. True, Acts I and II continue Zappa's tedious pandering to the novelty rock crowd, though at least Catholic Girls and Why Does It Hurt When I Pee are catchy. And Act III has some nice guitar solos if empty classic rock guitar heroism is your thing. That's all fine. But the material is padded out by tedious, monotonous, and unspeakably dull narration by Zappa in his goofy Central Scrutinizer voice, which completely ruins the flow of the album and completely fails to disguise the fact that Zappa took a bunch of utterly unrelated songs and crammed them into something resembling a story.

And on top of that, even though there are good moments such as I have outlined, they're hardly of the standard of the material on Uncle Meat, We're Only In It For the Money, One Size Fits All or other classic Zappa creations. It's far from Zappa's worst concept album - that would have to be the horrendous Thing-Fish, with its shamelessly recycled material botched with mammy-isms and the horrible acting from the "cast" - but it's a long way from his best concept album, or his best novelty rock record, or his best fusion album, or his best guitar solo collection.

There are as many different reasons to listen to a Frank Zappa record as there are Frank Zappa fans, but they all have one thing in common: pick any type of enjoyment you might wish to derive from a Zappa album, and there'll be one that delivers it better and with less bullshit filler than Joe's Garage.

Ratings only

  • MoogHead
  • JimmyJazz
  • zrong
  • The_Jester
  • Drummer
  • POW
  • Tychovski
  • The Block

Write/edit review

You must be logged in to write or edit review

JMA TOP 5 Jazz ALBUMS

Rating by members, ranked by custom algorithm
Albums with 30 ratings and more
A Love Supreme Post Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
Kind of Blue Cool Jazz
MILES DAVIS
Buy this album from our partners
The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady Progressive Big Band
CHARLES MINGUS
Buy this album from our partners
Blue Train Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
My Favorite Things Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners

New Jazz Artists

New Jazz Releases

Rebecca Kilgore Trio Vol. 1 Vocal Jazz
REBECCA KILGORE
Buy this album from MMA partners
Solo Post-Fusion Contemporary
RICARDO SILVEIRA
Buy this album from MMA partners
Flee & Free Fusion
KAORU HASHIMOTO
Buy this album from MMA partners
Steven Feifke Big Band : Kinetic Big Band
STEVEN FEIFKE
Buy this album from MMA partners
Sometime Ago Vocal Jazz
MEREDITH D' AMBROSIO
Buy this album from MMA partners
More new releases

New Jazz Online Videos

Ricardo Silveira_Solo_Luiza
RICARDO SILVEIRA
js· 5 hours ago
Steven Feifke Big Band - Nica's Dream
STEVEN FEIFKE
js· 1 day ago
More videos

New JMA Jazz Forum Topics

More in the forums

New Site interactions

More...

Latest Jazz News

members-submitted

More in the forums

Social Media

Follow us