Matti P
Eva Cassidy passed away while working on her first solo studio album, so Eva By Heart was completed by her producer (and ex beloved) Chris Biondo. The list of accompanying musicians -- and the variety of instruments -- is enhanced from the basic combo that had played on Live at Blues Alley, and includes e.g. organ, violin, trumpet, trombone and saxophone. Eva herself plays guitars, keyboards and cello. To cite Joel E. Siegel's liner notes, Eva By Heart is "Cassidy's artistic testament, demonstrating the scope, versatility and depth of her talents. She was attracted to songs that express profound themes (love, loss, transcendence, redemption) drawn from a diversity of musical traditions which she transforms into haunting personal statements." Agreed!
'I know You by Heart' is a tender, acoustic ballad with a nuanced arrangement that adds a suitable dose of romantic strings and Eva's own background vocals. Also the soulful 'Time Is a Healer' was (co-)composed by Diane Scanlon directly for Eva, I presume. 'Wayfaring Stranger' and 'Wade in the Water' are traditional tunes. The listener doesn't need to be particularily blues-minded to enjoy Cassidy's bluesy and groovy versions, although the latter has a bit too much of clapping or finger-snapping for my taste.
The 1941 jazz/blues standard 'Blues in the Night' is for me the most familiar as Julie London's sensual version. Eva's version is in a word "big", perhaps a bit too crowded in the arrangement. 'Songbird' is Christine McVie's FLEETWOOD MAC song and very suitable for Eva. 'Need Your Love So Bad' is a blues duet with Chuck Brown with whom Eva had recorded an album in 1992. 'Say Goodbye' is an OK mid-tempo song, nothing special.
The relaxed, guitar oriented arrangement on Doug MacLeod's 'Nightbird' has both gospel and country. A lot of vocal harmonies again. 'Waly Waly'(Trad.) is the most serene and slowest track, and my personal favourite. I remember the traditional 'How Can I Keep From Singing?' as ENYA's serene version, but Eva Cassidy makes it a full-blooded soul gospel number that I personally don't enjoy very much.
I feel I oughta appreciate this album more than I do in the end. Eva is excellent on whatever she brings to the table, but the choice of material could be better, given the vast amount of posthumous recordings that were to be released later, and I'm not completely happy with all the arrangements that occasionally get too big. "Less is more" is a proverb that suits Eca Cassidy perfectly, but here that wisdom is materialized less than I'd prefer.