JOHN COLTRANE — My Favorite Things

Jazz music community with review and forums

JOHN COLTRANE - My Favorite Things cover
4.73 | 59 ratings | 2 reviews
Buy this album from MMA partners

Album · 1961

Filed under Hard Bop


A1 My Favorite Things 13:41
A2 Everytime We Say Goodbye 5:39
B1 Summertime 11:31
B2 But Not For Me 9:35

Total Time: 40:37

Bonus Tracks
5.My Favorite Things, Part 1 (Single Version) 2:45
6.My Favorite Things, Part 2 (Single Version) 3:02


John Coltrane – soprano saxophone (1 & 2), tenor saxophone (tracks 3 & 4)
McCoy Tyner – piano
Steve Davis – bass
Elvin Jones – drums

About this release

Atlantic 1361(US)

My Favorite Things was recorded October 21, 1960; Summertime was recorded October 24, 1960; Everytime We Say Goodbye and But Not For Me were recorded October 26, 1960, at Atlantic Studios, New York City

Thanks to snobb, Abraxas for the updates


More places to buy jazz & JOHN COLTRANE music


Specialists/collaborators reviews

The Sound of Music the film would be the last place you would expect to produce one of the greatest Jazz tracks ever but that sure is the case with "My Favourite Things" Soprano Saxophone rules with the modal approach that John Coltrane took to this tune and the results were magnificent.This was where John Coltrane began to change with his approach to Jazz by discarding his Bop sound with a Modal appraoch which is working within the parameters of certain chords which cuts out chord changes allowing the musician to improvise over the repitition of the chords that are chosen. In other words it returned more melody within Jazz as the composition is caught within that framework of chords. This album has melody without doubt and often one hears from people not into Jazz ," but where is the tune". Well the tune is here and what John Coltrane has done with this simple tune is extrodainary with his use of this new approach in music and after this album which was his first in this style he would never go back to Bop but head out the opposite direction into Avante Garde. This is the first album also where he introduced his his new Quartet format and maybe the greatest creative period for him with the assistance of McCoy Tyner on piano who made such an important contribution. Steve Davis on bass and Elvin Jones on drums who like McCoy Tyner would be with this band through some of the most creative approach to Jazz ever. John Coltrane is the master of tenor saxophone but here he takes up soprano and takes that instrument to heights that nobody thought possible and the melody ,it is all there.

The title tune from the album is just short of fourteen minutes and the time length is not even noticable as this is taken to heights that are simply mesmerising. McCoy Tyner on piano begins the intro and the band with John Coltrane join putting down the theme as well a small solo from him which then McCoy Tyner uses to launch into one gorgeous solo with his approach which goes for over four minutes and always one can hear the theme within. John's turn and this is where within the composition some of the most amazing soprano sax was ever recorded. He stretches those notes like gum and the notes within notes could be the best description of the loops and swirls within the solo but always on the tune. The ending to the tune is simply breath taking and you do not want it to finish and John seems to oblige by keeping things going. Soprano saxophone is played again with next one "Everytime We Say Goodbye" which seems to be more restrained than the title as it is a quite piece with John opening proceedings and one can hear feel of the title within. McCoy Tyner follows on with some beautiful touch. He music always has that joyous feel with how he plays." Summertime" from Porgy and Bess is one of those tunes that nearly every genre of music done but not like this. John Coltrane is back on tenor and he captures the tune and wrings it out could be a great description for his approach. All the band get to have a crack with solos in this one. The album finishes up with " But Not For me" and is the most straight forward played tune but is anything really straight forward as John gives another of those solo's on tenor with his approach.

The songs that were chosen are all from theatre productions ( Musicals) and taken to heights that could only have been done by John Coltrane with the assistance of one of the best pianists and drummers in Jazz history. Steve Davis on Bass is no slouch either. Masterpiece in Jazz most definitely and one that is right up the top of the ladder. The only issue with the album I have is,"They could have done better with the cover".

Members reviews

Sean Trane
If Coltrane’s previous Atlantic label albums (Giant Steps and Coltrane Jazz) still had an old style of jazz, MFT is definitely taking a GIANT LEAP here, and his future forays in modal jazz improvisations take roots in the present opus’ two lengthy tracks. By this time, Coltrane had found an intuitive drummer in Elvin Jones, ones that would play more with him than with the drummer, and even more special, he had just found THE pianist that would help develop the transcendental moods he needed for Coltrane to become Trane. Indeed, a considerable part of Trane’s ascensional departure is to be attributed to McCoy Tyner’s outstanding and groundbreaking piano work, not least because of his unusually gifted left hand use.

One might consider MFT as the “hinge album” (or at least “one of them”) in Coltrane’s career, because while it is still very much a trad-jazz album (all four tracks are old standard reprises), yet Coltrane and Tyner go in lengthy modal explorations. Don’t get me wrong, we’re still far away from ALS or Ascenscion, but the seeds are planted in what would really become Trane’s Favourite Things, since he will rework that tune almost right up to the end of his all-too-short career. Right from Tyner’s instantly recognizable first notes, you know something will happen different than the ground covered in most of the great jazzmen in the 50’s (of which Coltrane was one of them). Yup, even the greater piano players of the previous two decades (beit Powell, Ellington, Monk or B. Evans), Tyner’s inimitable ivory ticklings are out of this world (well that world back then, anyway).

It’s rather unfortunate that this awesome 13-mins+ not-so standard cover is followed by a lacklustre Everytime that breaks the spell (I was never much a Porter fan), especially in the CD version, where it is sandwiched between the other giant tune, Gershwin’s Summertime. Again Tyner’s piano makes the difference between Trane’s version and all of the previous and future reprises. The album ends with another (but this time over-elongated and aptly-titled) Gershwin tune But Not For Me.

Of course what you’ll hear in this album will find much more space in future albums, including his next Africa/brass (his first for the Impulse! label) and a little later in Olé Coltrane (his last Atlantic label album) and so forth. So while this album has a very commercial appeal, since its title track was Trane’s best known number/hit, but it’s also the start of his more experimental and transcendental albums, a period that will culminate with A Love Supreme. As a matter of fact, MFT and Olé could’ve easily been Impulse! label albums.

Ratings only

  • bone
  • Mssr_Renard
  • Brown Clown
  • blackbird
  • karolcia
  • SuperMetro
  • stefanbedna
  • Anomaly05
  • teo12
  • LittleJake
  • wthii
  • Hohesc
  • Decao
  • MoogHead
  • Perdido
  • JimmyJazz
  • Pekka
  • Fant0mas
  • liontime
  • bytor2112
  • St Tree Fun
  • KK58
  • Ponker
  • yair0103
  • AucaCoyan
  • irock85
  • jeromeknvb
  • Amilisom
  • BlueNote
  • Ryu
  • JBThazard
  • usul
  • F611
  • petrica
  • Moahaha
  • sodr2
  • Anster
  • TheEraser
  • Reg
  • mzztrd
  • GMs
  • chuckyspell
  • barchios
  • Croteau
  • darkshade
  • Drummer
  • Krilons Resa
  • MitchNZ
  • jpmonterc
  • darkprinceofjazz
  • Hawkwise
  • Noak2
  • zorn1
  • richby
  • Sancho Panza
  • Tychovski
  • Polo

Write/edit review

You must be logged in to write or edit review


Rating by members, ranked by custom algorithm
Albums with 30 ratings and more
A Love Supreme Post Bop
Buy this album from our partners
Kind of Blue Cool Jazz
Buy this album from our partners
The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady Progressive Big Band
Buy this album from our partners
Blue Train Hard Bop
Buy this album from our partners
My Favorite Things Hard Bop
Buy this album from our partners

New Jazz Artists

New Jazz Releases

Dell, Lillinger, Westergaard : DLW Extended Beats Avant-Garde Jazz
Buy this album from MMA partners
No Words Needed Latin Jazz
Buy this album from MMA partners
More new releases

New Jazz Online Videos

Star Eyes
js· 12 hours ago
Bags' groove
js· 1 day ago
More videos

New JMA Jazz Forum Topics

More in the forums

New Site interactions


Latest Jazz News


More in the forums

Social Media

Follow us