CHARLES MINGUS Mingus Mingus Mingus Mingus Mingus jazz music review by js

CHARLES MINGUS Mingus Mingus Mingus Mingus Mingus

Album · 1963 · Hard Bop

4.5/5 · 2012-12-29
js

“Mingus, Mingus, Mingus, Mingus, Mingus” was Charles Mingus’ last studio album for quite a while and found him looking back over a very fruitful period in his life and re-recording some major pieces from that period. Having just recorded his extremely ambitious “The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady”, you get the feeling that Mingus just wanted to blow off some steam with this album and forgo new material in favor of improving the old and just having a fun jam session with some of his favorite musicians. Although there is only one new tune on here (“Celia”), Mingus and his crew did not check their creativity at the door, quite the contrary, all of these new arrangements of old Mingus tunes are bursting with energy and creativity and likewise are often christened with new titles. For instance, “II B.S.” is “Haitian Fight Song” modernized by replacing its original blues changes with repetitions of the main fighting riff.

It’s the creativity of the ensemble work that makes this album stand out. There are two different groups on here, but they share many players and both have an uncanny ability to merge intuitively. This is brought out the most on ballads like “I X Love” and “Theme for Lester Young” ("Goodby Pork Pie Hat”), where the members trade off backing phrases that smear across the bar lines and create shifting tone colors that sound fresh with every replay. There are many great soloists on “Mingus, Mingus”, but honorable mention goes to Charles Mariano, whose slippery tonality mixes well with Mingus’ sliding ensemble sound, and Jaki Byard whose piano work often acts as a glue for all the player’s disparate voices. On album closer, “Hora Decubitus”, Eric Dolphy makes a grand entrance with a hair raising solo, you can tell he is going for the grand slam, and except for a few stumbles, he gets awfully close.

Some have criticized this album for its lack of new material. Probably the best way to see “Mingus, Mingus” is as a sort of “live” album played in the studio. These tracks have some of the most creative ensemble work you will hear in the world of jazz.

4 months ago
Permalink
Report #241559

Share this review

Review Comments

Post a public comment below | Send private message to the reviewer

Please login to post a shout

dreadpirateroberts wrote:

4 months ago

Yeah, almost aggressively so? Especially 'Better Get Hit in Yo' Soul' & the opener, raw. Love the description of them as playing it live in the studio too.

js wrote:

4 months ago

I definitely prefer these versions, much more swagger, confidence, creativity and looseness.

dreadpirateroberts wrote:

4 months ago

Great review, John - I love this album, I think I even prefer a fair few of these versions over the originals.

Member Zone

Username:

Password:

Stay signed in

Not Yet Registered?

Forgotten Your Password?

Jazz Sub-genres

Artists Alpha-index

A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
Y
Z
V.A.

JMA TOP 5 Jazz ALBUMS

Rating by members, ranked by custom algorithm

Kind of Blue Cool Jazz
MILES DAVIS

A Love Supreme Post Bop
JOHN COLTRANE

The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady Post Bop
CHARLES MINGUS

'Out to Lunch!' Avant-Garde Jazz
ERIC DOLPHY

Milestones Hard Bop
MILES DAVIS

More results and filters

New Jazz Artists

METRONOME ALL STARS Bop
MATTY MATLOCK Dixieland
RODRIGO AMADO Avant-Garde Jazz
GÜNTER CHRISTMANN Avant-Garde Jazz
LOUIS METCALF Swing
JUNIE MORRISON Funk
BERT LOWN Big Band
STEVE MASAKOWSKI Post Bop
CLARION FRACTURE ZONE Classic Fusion
THE DANISH RADIO JAZZ ORCHESTRA Progressive Big Band
DAVID BOYKIN Avant-Garde Jazz
DON MENZA Hard Bop
FRANK STROZIER Hard Bop
CECILE MCLORIN SALVANT Vocal Jazz
SHADOWFAX Jazz Related Improvisation
JACOPO MAZZA Post Bop
RENÉ MCLEAN World Fusion
ROSY MCHARGUE Dixieland
JIM MCNEELY Progressive Big Band
DAVE MCKENNA Swing

New Jazz Releases

What's Your Story Vocal Jazz
KRISTIN KORB

I Thought About You: A Tribute to Chet Baker Vocal Jazz
ELIANE ELIAS

The Flame Alphabet Avant-Garde Jazz
RODRIGO AMADO

Dysnomia Nu Jazz
DAWN OF MIDI

Lamaçal (Live at Portalegre Jazzfest) Classic Fusion
LAMA

More new releases

New Free Jazz MP3 download/stream

SUPERDENSECRUSHLOADFACTOR Vandalize Stock Photos
Decease Estates · 2012 · Jazz Related Improvisation
PAUL BARBARIN Eh La Bas
And His New Orleans Jazz · 1955 · Original New Orleans Jazz
PAT METHENY Lakes
Watercolors · 1977 · Classic Fusion
PAT METHENY San Lorenzo
Pat Metheny Group · 1978 · Classic Fusion
PAT METHENY Sueño con México
New Chautauqua · 1979 · Post-Fusion Contemporary
PAT METHENY Unity Village
Bright Size Life · 1976 · Post Bop
LALO SCHIFRIN Breaks
Gone With the Wave · 1964 · Jazz Soundtracks
JOE PASS Cavalerie
For Django · 1964 · Bop
ISAAC HAYES Soulsville
Shaft · 1971 · Jazz Soundtracks
ISAAC HAYES Fugitive
Lifetime Thing · 1981 · Jazz Related RnB