In Greg Milner's excellent history of the recording industry, 'Perfecting Sound Forever', he describes the earliest forms of recorded music as holding two divergent philosophies of what a recording is, or should be. The first tried to reproduce the sound in the room as closely as possible, the second insisted that recordings should transcend that sound because the feeling of listening in that room cannot be replicated. Such contrasting ideas of what 'the truth' is permeate this bracing yet addictive autobiography of Sonny Simmons (1933-2021), a musician who was critically neglected throughout his long life yet admired by many musicians, by those who knew. He lived to a ripe old age of 87 but also cheated death several times. He was often thought of as an 'outside' player but maintained throughout his career that anything venturing 'out' must emerge from an 'in', coming as he did from a background in bebop. He was a man of contradictions, and in this book, which reads almost like a transcribed sermon, he reveals how deep those contradictions go.
Many jazz fans don't even know who Simmons was. Collaborations on record in 1963 with both Eric Dolphy and Elvin Jones might have cemented the reputation of other players, but something of a recurring theme here is the persistent failure of Simmons's career to 'take off', and as a result he isn?t talked about nearly as much as he should be.
My first encounter with the music of Sonny Simmons was on 'The Cry', an album co-led with flautist Prince Lasha released in 1962, a musician he worked again on 1967's album 'Firebirds'. The two players seem poles apart, Simmon's fiery aggression contrasting with Lasha's more contemplative playing. Simmons's comments on the music were not included on the album's liner notes, saying 'The way Prince Lasha was playing pissed me off throughout the whole session.'
Lasha then proceeded to take most of the credit, having his name first on the album despite Simmons having written most of the music, including, if we are to believe his testimony, most of the tunes credited solely to Lasha. It's easy to assume that two names on a jazz LP hang together like the best of friends, but for Simmons, Lasha pops up again and again as someone he can't shake off, someone he sees as a fraud who 'mesmerised the white boys with all his fast New York shit' but essentially couldn't play.
But Lasha's not the only musician to get it in the neck: Simmons gleefully dishes the dirt on some of the music's most cherished heavy hitters. When listening to the later Coltrane records, Simmons remembers that 'when it came time for Pharoah Sanders to play, I would take that off and put it back to where John started. I would never listen to that shit''. On Joe Henderson, he gives with one hand and takes with the other:
'It's cool. I love Joe's music; I love his playing. But I knew him. He was a chickenshit mother
.'
There's something about the greats being slated in such a comical way that reminds us that they, and their rivals, were only human. And that, as Black American musicians they had come up through a social system that sought to keep them down at every opportunity and created the need for self-preservation that finds its voice in music, and its nemesis, one could argue, in addiction. And it's this aspect of the book that packs the biggest punch.
It's a gruelling read in many ways, and like Miles Davis's accounts of his own mother's beatings in his autobiography, there's plenty in the early chapters detailing Simmons's Louisiana childhood on Sicily Island that prepare us for the chaos ahead. Feel the snap of the branch in the effortless poetry of the following line:
'When I was getting out of line, my mother would take off a peach tree switch - a little limb alive with sap - and swing it and it would pop.'
I'm no psychotherapist, but it's not hard to see how women are subsequently referred to as either -goddesses' or 'pistols'. His misogyny, as his co-writer Marc Chaloin notes, is out for all to see, as when he compliments his first wife Gloria on being 'the kind of woman that don't try to be equal to me or give me a problem', it's a pretty shocking viewpoint, but one that was probably more common at the time than we can possibly imagine now. It's the ease with which he declares it that smarts - we know these attitudes persist even today, but they are kept out of sight (Tate and his gormless followers aside).
But as horrific as this kind of attitude is, in some ways the sheer poverty that follows Simmons throughout his life overshadows it, and it's hard not to see a direct correlation. Again, his childhood gives a chilling premonition of the toughness of his life to come. Family life sounds like it was unbearably tough. After being attached to a length of rope by his dad, he was floated out into the creek near his home and used as live bait to catch alligators. At the last minute his father would drag him back to shore with the reptiles in pursuit before they would be killed with a spear to the head once they were within striking distance. Apparently, you could eat the tails, and business was business. Simmons sums up his thoughts thus:
'...it was a funny thing but that didn't frighten me. I don't think I've ever been frightened by anything except poverty.'
Despite his openly macho attitude to women, he decided to 'get me a white lady that plays trumpet?, after which he met Barbara Donald, who became his wife and the co-leader of his band. It?s hard to imagine that the idea preceded the reality here, that he was actively looking for a female trumpet player and then found her'but these questionable memories crop up enough that the reader would have to take some of the so-called facts with a pinch of salt. This is not, however, the kind of jazz biography where we are given serial numbers of first releases and other discographic details. This is pure grit, the feeling of the truth.
His union, both musical and matrimonial, with Barbara Donald was not a popular move amongst his fellow black musicians and, whilst the US racial politics of the time in the black community were far too complex for me as a white British man to comment on, that complexity must nevertheless be noted. Again, those contradictions surface - Sonny Simmons, the equality trailblazer, amidst the rampant sexism of his private life. When she finally left him for another musician, taking their two children with her, his life spiralled downwards into drug addiction. Simmons had always warned his fellow musicians off heroin, but here is another book about the life of a black jazz musician where one feels it was an almost unavoidable trajectory, and where one personal tragedy too many forced him over the edge.
Simmons was a survivor ('I played on the streets from 1980 to 1994, 365 days a year'), living a brutal life that many modern-day musicians would barely recognise, yet there's always been a temptation to admire the sense of purpose, of genuine life-or-death energy that drove musicians to play for money for a fix. This is patronising and dangerous, and if Simmons's story has one overriding quality, it is that it normalises the world in which he lived, shows the reality of his hand-to-mouth existence ('I would go to the back of exclusive restaurants downtown and get the best food out of the garbage can. That's how I ate...'). There are countless stories from this part of his life that are almost unbearably grim, and there's always the niggling feeling that at least some of it was self-made, a feeling I tried in vain to put to the back of my mind. At the same time, he describes in detail you can almost feel, the process of music making, almost as something to be shed like a skin:
'I'm working at this joint, I'm full of good heroin, and I'm having fun'. when I began to play...my mind shifted from evil to good...To be able to express the music in me was like a cleansing ritual...'
Simmons's conflicting moral positions, which Chaloin is careful to draw attention to in the introduction, are many, shape shifting in the way that a life perpetually dodging bullets and knives while living on the breadline would surely encourage. And yet there are moments of profound empathy, including this passage regarding Ornette Coleman:
'I saw this sadness about him, from rejection...I'm looking at a brother who's gonna be a frontier man for the new music in the near future'.And I see all this sadness in the brother - how he had been browbeaten and treated like a dog...'
And then there's the music, which any good biography should have you digging for after each chapter. And in this case, the sense of discovery is real as so much of it is relatively unknown. The early work is full of defiance, fuelled by superhuman levels of practice, discipline and imagination, but by the time of later albums like 'I'll See You When I Get There' there's a kind of simmering pain that runs through his tone, something like that of the later Rahsaan Roland Kirk, the air surging and faltering as if constantly falling and getting back up. That seems to have been the story of Sonny Simmons's life, a man who left a trail of chaos and pain, but also, for his fans, joy and transcendence, in the wake of the music he made in his efforts to make peace with the demons that pursued him. He could be unbearably cruel, particularly to his close family, in that way people governed by narcotic addiction often are, yet also very loyal to those in the worlds of music and drugs who saved his life on so many occasions. Perhaps, in wanting to document his life, he wanted to make amends for the bad, and acknowledge the good, and this was his way to set things straight. It may not all be the truth, but it certainly feels like it.
from https://ukjazznews.com