JazzMusicArchives.com Homepage
Forum Home Forum Home >Jazz Music Lounges >Books and Miscellaneous Reviews
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - Creativity ... again!!!
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Register Register  Login Login

Creativity ... again!!!

 Post Reply Post Reply
Author
Message
Moshkiae1 View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 19 Jul 2025
Location: Grok City
Status: Offline
Points: 124
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Moshkiae1 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Topic: Creativity ... again!!!
    Posted: 10 Jun 2026 at 8:32am
Hi,
Quote
...
It all starts with an idea. Something that can anchor the musicians into a common place. That being said, I was going to post the question about how you envision the process unfolding.

I've been involved with recording/production enough to know that most songs begin with a lick or melody that needs to be developed. Some begin with lyrics that need the melody to support that. Some begin with a rhythm that sparks the melody and in turn draws out the lyrics.

To suggest that NO album ever began with lyrics is naive. I'm pretty sure Jim Morrison wrote his lyrics (poems) and the band supported them with their music, yes?
...


Wanted to post this here, as it really explains how little folks listen to different musics and what they entail and come from.

Here are my takes, from my book on improvisation (somewhat!!!) ... which has roots in something else, mainly improvisational theater and film, something that the majority of musicians disdain, and think its garbage ... and then you get fans that think they own the idea of creativity, which, somehow, in my book is worse.

For rock, and uneducated musicians, "improvisation" starts with a lick, a sound, or some kind of accident (so to speak), which helps develop the sound into an idea. In this thought the SOUND creates the idea. In total essence and design, this idea would not be an "improvisation" which, by all concepts and thoughts would have no beginning and no end, and this idea is important to consider ... for it to be "improvised" it has to be "free" of all constraints and anything surrounding the exercise. This was a very strong and valid idea defined in theater by Peter Brook, in England and then France, while rock musicians stuck to scales and more notes, and faster, and then, OF COURSE, much louder to make you feel like you remember the moment!

Conversely, jazz could be said to be slightly different, as one person goes one way, and other might join in, which you and I might consider was something that Miles Davis was working on ... and no one ever knew where he was going ... until he was out of breath and pretty much pointed to someone to give him a break!!!

The main difference between the two is that one ends up being very mechanical, and in rock music it is that awful snare drum the last 40 years making sure the other folks are in time and with ... the leader!

The thought that "melody" is what makes music, is bizarre, when one considers how many and how much experimental music has been around for over 50/60 years, and how "melody" was not exactly the driving force. So, it is much safer to say that this is the case in "POP MUSIC", as it is the material that sells the most, thus has the largest amount of listeners, and as is the case with some places where a lot of these things are posted, it merely reflects the idea that the record company is right, and the public is wrong, which was something that the FM stations in the 1970's showed us was incorrect about the music listeners and stations, until it was completely raped by a lot of corporate consortiums to take the music choices out of the hands of the "public", and turn all of those stations to mechanic nothings playing the hists, or classic stuff that you have heard at least 100 times.

I'm not sure that Jim Morrison started with just the poetry or a few notes here and there, because he was improvising live on stage, something that might make a lot of musicians uncomfortable, but for his mates, was just fine ... with one special detail that rock fans don't like to look at ... these folks were fairly strong students and at least Jim Morrison, we know, was into film ... thus, something could enter his mind, be it in concert or not, and he would run with it, because the sequence of images was strong ... and that is the greatest essence of a poet ... or writer ... learning to live with their vision and finding words for it ... rock musicians are limited here, because they STOP, to make sure that this or that has to be done to make their creativity better, and when you do this, your vision STOPS, and continuing it is difficult, or at the very least, extremelly different, with a feel that is quite far from what you started with.

Music history wants us to believe that the notes, or the sequence of the notes is what created the words, or at least the feelings ... that helped define some words later. The sequencing of notes, or sounds is likely to be the driver here, since you close your eyes, and you just flow ... and it doesn't matter what you do ... it just happens. That words show up is more of a comfort sone here, but to say, AND think, that they match each other is bizarre since the feeling will not be the same on different nights (for example) or performances. Thus, as is the case in popular music and the instructors of the card board version of the history of music, this means that, and that means this, and MINOR is sad, and all kinds of bizarre ideas related to a theory that has less to do with "music" itself, than it does with the concept that we believe that we were intelligent and knew what we were doing when these things were written down ... and this is an area that a lot of films love to make fun of when they study well known musicians ... I like to joke that these are not studies, because they only look at one thing in it.

It reminds me of the various symphonies and times going back to Mozart (it wasn't really done before!!!), that all music had a story, and opera relies on this really well, though I can not usually say that the music and the words match each other, thogh sometimes one moment ends up showing somethig that is exceptional ... and one example is Beniamino Gigli doing an aria from TOSCA and all of a sudden all other tenors don't sound so good, or as intuitive, and emotional as Gigli did.

Since that time, and reading the description of the various symphonies in the 19th century and what "they meant" is nerve wrecking and bizarre ... you are supposed to see what you are being told, in other words, you are an idiot that has no feelings and has to be told what things are. Such an upper class society of things tp the point that they still spend their time telling you that music is for the upper class, not the public, with one problem ... financially anyone saying that will never get another job within the music industry.

And for the recod, no melody ever really drew out the lyrics ... this is an idea that has been glued to our imagination, and in the end, it deprives us of the ability to find our own set of words and visuals to carry on with the melody. This has been an important thing that is very visible in a lot of movies with exceptional music, that was used not to get you to fly with the kiss behind the blue or pink scrim with the idea, but to confuse and ensure that you get the very same thought and idea as the actor and writer at that moment ... confusion, and you don't know ... but then, what are you doing to learn how to see anything in these moments?

That is the question that helps with "improvisation" ... not ideas that are too many years old, and now we speak of them as if they were the Holiest of books. Such insane idea my friend ...

NOTE: To suggest that no album was ever begun by the lyrics, is the same thing as saying that those folks have, obviously never heard music, from classical to jazz to many other styles. But for "pop musik" experts, the lyrics are more important than the music, of course!!!

Edited by Moshkiae1 - 12 Jun 2026 at 6:37am
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply
  Share Topic   

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 10.16
Copyright ©2001-2013 Web Wiz Ltd.

This page was generated in 0.155 seconds.