JazzMusicArchives.com Homepage
Forum Home Forum Home >Jazz Music Lounges >Jazz Bands, Artists and Genres Appreciation
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - Harmonica ... a small profile ...
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Register Register  Login Login

Harmonica ... a small profile ...

 Post Reply Post Reply
Author
Message Reverse Sort Order
Moshkiae1 View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 19 Jul 2025
Location: Grok City
Status: Offline
Points: 124
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Moshkiae1 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Topic: Harmonica ... a small profile ...
    Posted: 13 Dec 2025 at 5:47pm
Originally posted by WebLing WebLing wrote:

---Make sure you listen to Terje Rypdal ...
Speaking about Terje Rypdal. He wrote "Modulations for harmonica and orchestra" (dedicated to Sigmund Groven). It is available on Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/intl-de/track/3909yVOUyM1wI5mbDk7WCj?si=87914c2294d4421f



Hi,

Terje has been on my lists since 1975 with ODYSSEY. I caught a Melody Maker advertising on the back pages for a concert with Ash Ra Tempel and Terje Rypdal ... the next week, the album Odyssey showed up at the station and it has been with me since and forever.

Of all things he did, my favorite has always been his guitar work with Dave Darling in the album EOS ... the prettiest thing ever and is so Jimi Hendrix in my ears! Make sure you turn down the opening song, as it is completely different and I think it must have been there for a reason to make sure that folks did not keep him locked up into a style or musical idea. It's a very loud attack, and not even TR typical I don't think!

Retired as I am, with limited income, purchasing new things is hard, so at times I have to cheat and catch listens elsewhere ... my CD's are still boxed which is preventing me from doing some more reviews.

Happy Holidays
Back to Top
WebLing View Drop Down
Forum Newbie
Forum Newbie


Joined: 22 Nov 2025
Status: Offline
Points: 2
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote WebLing Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 29 Nov 2025 at 5:37am
---Make sure you listen to Terje Rypdal ...
Speaking about Terje Rypdal. He wrote "Modulations for harmonica and orchestra" (dedicated to Sigmund Groven). It is available on Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/intl-de/track/3909yVOUyM1wI5mbDk7WCj?si=87914c2294d4421f



Edited by WebLing - 29 Nov 2025 at 5:38am
Back to Top
Moshkiae1 View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 19 Jul 2025
Location: Grok City
Status: Offline
Points: 124
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Moshkiae1 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 24 Nov 2025 at 5:14am
Hi,


Welcome to the Forum ... lovely to meet someone else ... smile time!

I can not locate anywhere where Larry Adler played this piece. However, at least one of his albums was made into a RCA Red Seal. And I can not locate where Larry Adler actually played this particular piece.

I'm going to clean up the write up, since I can not locate where I got that information either ... I started with as many links as I could find, but all of a sudden, nothing shows up ... but I think that Larry Adler was the only one that got RCA Red Seal recordings, although I have not checked Toots Thielmans.

https://www.discogs.com/search?q=larry+adler&type=all

Larry Adler Plays Harmonica Concertos Dedicated To Him (LP)<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>RCA Red Seal<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>SB 6786<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>UK<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>1968<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>

Plays Works For Harmonica And Orchestra (LP, Album)<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>RCA Red Seal<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>LSC-3078<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>US<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>1969<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>

Larry Adler Plays Works For Harmonica And Orchestra (LP, Stereo)<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>RCA Red Seal<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>SRA-2679<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>Japan<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>1969<span style="white-space:pre">     </span>

I wish that the information and record keeping for all of this stuff was better, but the harmonica, STILL, is not considered an important instrument for an orchestra, and kinda remains buried in blues and some bar stuff. I first heard it, btw, in Chicago in 1969 or so ... guess who played the harmonica?

Paul Butterfield.


I've heard a few of these guys ... Charley Musselwhite, Mississippi Charles Bevel (superb acoustic guitar and incredible voice), Chick Streetman to name a few ... always appreciate great music regardless of how it was done, and these folks "had it", where the majority of pop music, and rock music didn't and still doesn't.

Just recently I heard a "new album" by a band that has been around for 30 years, and it was the first time in 55 years that I thought ... not very good, just a bunch of geriatric kids playing kids' music. After all that time, all the band learned is to write another cheap song! I was so embarrassed about how I felt that I could not even post it, and will not name the album.

When stuff like that happens, I can't help end up looking for things like ... the harmonica ... just have to hear some music that has touch, feel, and taste ... instead of ______ ... now I'm sitting here and hope one day someone will use an electric guitar properly on an orchestra, instead of Mike Oldfield.

Make sure you listen to Terje Rypdal ... ECM all over it, and various albums of his are awesome ... check out the reviews section ... I haven't got that album yet, and am looking for it.


Edited by Moshkiae1 - 24 Nov 2025 at 5:53am
Back to Top
WebLing View Drop Down
Forum Newbie
Forum Newbie


Joined: 22 Nov 2025
Status: Offline
Points: 2
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote WebLing Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 22 Nov 2025 at 7:19am
Hi Moshkiae1

I am curious, you are mentioning the Jean Berger - Caribbean Concerto in you post and that there  is a RCA RED SEAL recording of Adler playing the concerto. I am not aware of that recording and could not find any reference to it.
Do you have a record or recording of it? I would be very much interested in it if it exists. I know that Adler had a tape recording of one of his live performances and I know that he was thinking of making a recording of it.
This is mentioned in one of Berger's interviews:
http://www.bruceduffie.com/berger.html


Back to Top
Moshkiae1 View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 19 Jul 2025
Location: Grok City
Status: Offline
Points: 124
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Moshkiae1 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 13 Oct 2025 at 9:28am
Hi,

Arthur Benjamin - Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra (1953)
1. Romanza 2. Canzona Semplice 3. Rondo Amabile
An unbelievable piece of music, that really defies the way that the instrument has been used, mostly for a few pop songs, and then one day, out of the blue you hear something like this and you are not ready for it ... and you have to adjust ... to it not being a "song", and relax a bit more so you are not expecting the song to resolve itself, and maybe you and I can come out of it with a smile and even so much as whistling a few moments of it.  The middle part, almost belongs in a Nicolas Roeg film, or a Ridley Scott film ... the two directors that have used music and know how to use it!

Jean-Francois Marcoux - Le Sommeil des Voeux (1990)
Not much information on this piece, and it tends towards the mode modern style of music, and it is quite progressive in its design compared to how you and I are used to hearing the harmonica. This is not Toots Theilmans. It is totally classically minded, and very adventurous, and possibly a tough listen, again, compared to how you and I are used to hearing a harmonica ... but when you hear these things, you wonder how an instrument that is so expressive, has been left behind by so many? I imagine that the harmonica was never really considered an instrument that fit an orchestra or the kind of music an orchestra plays ... and then you hear this ... The only thing listed is actually on the screenshow it says "starckwest" and it is actually "Sir Starck West" that played a lot of things on the harmonica. At least on this piece it is quite adventurous and very nice. A treat for the ears, although so different. This piece is more classical than it is anything else, and at times, it even feels like ... the harmonica is in the wrong place with the wrong instruments, but the modern quality and composition is fantastic, and in my book, it just helps the harmonica shine, like an electric guitar can't and won't!

Robert Russell Bennett - Concerto for Harmonica (1971)
RRB was a major arranger for a lot of the American musicals in the 1950's and 1960's. These included Jerome Kern, George Gershwin, Cole Porter, Kurt Weill and others. The Concert for Harmonica is less known or played and appears to list in 1971. Could not locate the piece to hear it. Compared to the works he was a part of, this thing is not important or has had anyone bother with it. SAD! 

Strange note: A man that helped make sure so many other folks sounded great, you don't think he could do that with a Harmonica? Logic in the trash can!

Jean Berger - Caribbean Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra (1940)
This piece of music was dedicated to Larry Adler, that had played so many Harmonica pieces and made them stand out with a flair that was incredible, and made all his playing come alive so well, and show how a Harmonica could be used with an Orchestra, or a solo instrument. A wonderful piece, that I think made sure that it included the soft touches and movements that Larry Adler was known for, that enchanted the instrument for so many folks, to give you an idea how well it was thought of. Larry Adler plays various compositions in several album, however I can not locate it being played by Larry Adler. This piece is really nice and spreads out well, though for my ears it lacks the sensuousness that Larry Adler brings to the table that is something that we love to listen to. This piece by Jean Berger, adds a bit more classical touches to Larry's style, if I can say that. Still very nice, though I think you will go for the Larry Adler recordings rather than this one, even though you should also have it.

Henry Cowell - Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra (1962)
One of the very far out and different composers that went on to bring forth several details about playing the piano that was extreme, including fists, arms and string plucking to the point of ... craziness, as audiences had a hard time with it, even in Europe. The harmonica in this piece is the lead all the way through and it is rather nice, although we will not be finding that usual melody parts that tends to bring up to the instrument. This is actually very strong stuff, and this many years later, it stands up really well, but it is so far and away from the commercial music thing that this would likely get more vitriolic discussions than he got to feel first hand. While different, it is actually a very nice piece, though you and I would likely feel that it is way too "classical" in its design, in order for it to stand up as something that we love to listen to and enjoy. The recording is really good, and amazing. The player is John Sebastian, who was the father of John Sebastian of "Lovin' Spoonful" fame.

Alexander Tcherepnin - Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra (1953)
Not as adventurous as the Henry Cowell piece John Sebastian played, but it is a really nice piece of music that uses the Harmonica well, although both you and I might not think that this is not the experimental thing that Henry Cowell gave us. We could say that this is more "conventional" and the Harmonica is really well used, and has moments where it leads the orchestra. A very nice piece which is easy on the ears, and not as experimental. It has a nice, and what I like to call "playful" moments for the harmonica which makes the piece more fun to listen to.

Norman Dello Joio - Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra (1948)
Also written for John Sebastian. Only the opening portion of this piece was I able to find on the net and it was a solo portion, or introduction to what might have been. Would like to have heard the rest of it.

Brett Deubner - Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra
Could not locate anything of this piece.

Walter Girnatis - Concertino
Could not locate anything on this piece.

Richard Hayman - Concerto (1978)
Could not locate this specific piece but Richard Hayman played a lot of well known songs and also worked with the Boston Pops Orchestra.

Hugo Herrmann - Concertino (1948)
Could not locate the piece.

Alan Hovhaness - Concerto No. 6, op. 114 (1953-4, for John Sebastian)
Found a lot of stuff, but not this.

George Kleinsinger - Street Corner Concerto (1942, for John Sebastian)
An incredible piece of music, totally different in the sense that everything you have heard was not on the menu, and all of a sudden, it's like a "story" is here for you via the harmonica playing with the orchestra. The visual on the toob, helps some, as it makes it theatrical, but the music is even more so, and the harmonica is incredible in that whole thing ... very different and totally special. An incredible piece of music. Worth a listen ... you gotta check this out, for its amazing design and flow. One of the best things I have ever heard for a harmonica ... heck, it would probably sound good on a violin, or something else.

Karl-Heinz Köper - Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra, Op. 12 (1961, for Tommy Reilly)
Apparently not considered an important piece of music, and is not listed on the toob. There are other compositions by this composer, but not this one. Probably not well known or thought to be as good as the other compositions of this person.

Serge Lancen - Concerto (1958, for Larry Adler)
Same situation as Karl-Heinz Koper.

Alan Langford: Concertante for Harmonica and Strings (1981, for Tommy Reilly)
Same situation as Karl-Heinz Koper

Howard Levy - Concerto for Diatonic Harmonica and Orchestra - first concerto for 10-hole harmonica and orchestra
Listed in several parts, it is an interesting listen, as it is not like a lot of other things, and it allows the harmonica to solo quite a bit, in setting up the parts for the orchestra, which makes it different ... however, there is a feeling that this is not complete, as far as my listen thinks. It is nice, but it seems missing parts.

Frank Lewin - Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra (1960, for John Sebastian)
Noted and listed but no performances found, and there is one note that it was still not performed. The fate of the harmonica, in general!!!

Terje Rypdal: Modulations for Harmonica and Orchestra (1981, for Sigmund Groven)
This is like listening to a lot of Terje's material. It is different, and the start for it, is not standing up to show off the harmonica, it is merely making sure that the harmonica leads the orchestra and it does beautifully, though it is moody within the style that Terje uses so well for his jazzy material. Here, it's hard to think of this as jazzy, as it is really well done and is likely defined as "classical", with special touches and moments for the harmonica. After searching for many pieces for harmonica, it is super nice to find one that stands out ... and it is very dreamy and laid back, and maybe I should use the word "quiet". You know what? You almost want that guitar with it, for a  duet like the one he did with David Darling in EOS. Wonderful listen, and you don't get the feeling that this is just some frivolous thing. Well done and defined music. Moody and neat. The part I like the best is that this is not a fun thing for the harmonica and it is treated very seriously and it could just as easily be a violin or another instrument. A very special piece, and totally different. 

Henri Sauguet - The Garden's Concerto (1970, for Claude Garden)
Nice. I keep thinking that this has one thing that many of the pieces mentioned above do not ... this felt "composed" and the Harmonica added the touches, to the score, and I say that because you just about can listen to the orchestra and not pay attention to the Harmonica. The music is nice and detailed, adding a nice touch to the whole thing, even if it has too much of the classical feel. That's to say, that I was not expecting the Harmonica to become one of the instruments in the orchestra ... but it kinda gives you the idea that while there are some great things composed that have had a Harmonica with it, most of them felt like it was just a free fomr thing and the Harmonica was not completely married to the orchestra ... and you can feel that here. It's nice, though, and you get the feeling -- cheating ... because of the title of the piece -- that you are in the garden and on occasion you hear the birds. Then, you really end up getting a nice feel for it all ... and I think that is a nice touch. Very different than a lot of the other pieces, but enjoyable. The player was named Garden, so my cheating is really cheap!

Henning Sommerro: Concertino for Harmonica and Orchestra (2008. for Sigmund Groven)
Sigmund Groven is a special player with a Harmonica, and the gentle and soft touches are incredible and the only thing that made this example not very good was that it was badly recorded and the harmonica did not get the sound touch that it deserved, though that was not a surprise, the accompanying piano was also badly recorded thus making the piece sound even more difficult to hear and evaluate properly, but at least, you could easily see that Sigmund Groven was a special player.

Michael Spivakovsky - Concerto (1951, for Tommy Reilly)
This piece is listed in 3 parts. 1) Fuocoso - Dance Drole. 2) Romance - Andante, dolce and 3) Scherzo. Allegro Ma Non Troppo. A very nice piece, that starts with a lot of orchestra, and then allows the Harmonica to do its thing, and eventually they come together, and it is interesting and different. You get the feeling that the instrument was well thought out and designed to fit into the orchestra, as if it were a part of it, and this is the nicest thing about it. To hear an instrument, exactly like all the others. And played beautifully. It's difficult to not enjoy this piece of music. Completely classical, and well defined and touched. 

Siegfried Steinkogler - Harmonica Concerto (2001, for Sigmund Groven)
Site had links blocked for purchase only. Could not locate this on the toob.

Vilém Tauský - Concertino (1963, for Tommy Reilly)
It starts out with a very classical feeling, which makes it seem like the harmonica will be in the background, but it picks up as time goes by. The orchestral side of it all is very nice, and eventually complements the harmonica well, though you and I would want to have it be the other way around, like an electric guitar would do. The harmonica here is nice, but it has very little amplification, if any, and it gets drowned out by the orchestra on occasion. Some really nice touches in the orchestral side of things, though.

Alexander Tcherepnin - Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra, Op. 86 (1953, for John Sebastian)
This piece is ... more like it! In many examples already mentioned, it was always somewhat clear that the Harmonica was not taken seriously, as it played only the equivalent of a song, although at times it seemed more than that, but the actual feeling of it being important and valuable as an instrument on any orchestra was not there ... and here, IT IS! An outstanding piece that is magnificently played and the harmonica, finally, does not play in the background to the orchestra ... it's right out front! And what a touch it has, and illustrates what any instrument can do to any piece of music, that is not a part of the thinking in classical music, if you don't mind my saying so ... this is outstanding, and then some ... and worth a listen, and it is a real concert, and not a song! Exceptional ... and unbelievably wonderful. The one thing you can say is that the composer appreciated the harmonica well enough to allow it to feature and stand up to the orchestra and ... in the hands of Mr. John Sebastian, it was just ... the best Harmonica work I have ever heard. Totally awesome. Any orchestra out there, you want some attention? Wake up to this!

Heitor Villa-Lobos - Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra (1955, for John Sebastian)
A nice piece, that sadly was not well recorded and the Harmonica gets lost and often not heard properly ... it hurts the piece a lot, as the Harmonica does not end up showing itself as major in this whole thing as it should, so we can hear a real concerto. We hear some flashes of the Harmonica but often with the orchestra, it gets totally drown out and some parts are left behind, many of which would probably be considered the best in this work. In my book, this does not help show Heitor Villa-Lobos as a major composer, whole music is handled with importance, instead of rather not as good concert as you and I would like to see and hear it ... when this was done might have made the grade (75 years ago almost), but it is weird that the whole thing was not discussed and fixed, when this was the time that classical music really started to show its chops in the recording of everything ... but in a sad sort f way, keeping this a low key work, kinda takes away from the composer's ability a lot. Compared to how we would look at it today, we would say that piece suffers because both the conductor and recording did not know how to accentuate the quality of the work. Compare this to the Tcherepnin work done at about the same time, to get an idea, of how some folks knew what they were doing, as opposed to some folks that didn't. Where is Steven Wilson, when we really need him?

One other sad note here, and this is not exactly a criticism, as much as it is ... the appreciation for the Harmonica. In the last movement when Mr. Staneck solos, the orchestra and the conductor look bored for the most part, and it made me feel sad ... and that conductor needs lessons in conducting, so he can stop waving the baton for no reason, and move it with feeling instead! This music needs feeling ... not mechanics.

Meiro Sugawara - Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra (1978, for Joe Sakimoto)
Could not locate this piece anywhere. Most of the stuff listed for this composer is attached to his having done music for a lot of anime stuff. could not evaluate this at all otherwise.

Graham Whettam - Concerto Scherzoso, Op. 9 (1951, Larry Adler)
In comparison to the work above by Villa-Lobos with the really poor recording, listen to Larry Adler in this piece ... there is no way that even the orchestra is going to stand up to this player, and he delivers and then some. I enjoyed this for the Harmonica gymnastics, more than anything else ... because Larry Adler is too good and special all around, and he makes sure the piece is heard. Very nice piece, but you will end up just listening to Larry Adler and not think about the orchestra. This man can play and no orchestra will be able to stand up to him!

Corky Siegel's Chamber Blues ? Chamber Blues (1994 ? Alligator)
It looks like most of this stuff was done as blues and you will find live recordings of it, and it has a special feeling ... like you are there, which makes the music even more important, though it is not always the harmonica stuff, still it is special. And unlike some of these other pieces, it is special without having to tell you that this is serious classical music!!! And that is how the Harmonica is generally accepted and seen ... an instrument that deserves a lot more respect than it has gotten in the past 75 years of the life of recording music generally speaking. 



Edited by Moshkiae1 - 24 Nov 2025 at 5:37am
Back to Top
Moshkiae1 View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 19 Jul 2025
Location: Grok City
Status: Offline
Points: 124
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Moshkiae1 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 13 Oct 2025 at 9:27am
Hi,

The short of it ... in case you just want a touch ...

Larry Adler and specially his Arthur Benjamin work.

Henry Cowell and the Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra

George Kleinsinger  and the Street Corner Concerto

Terje Rypdal and Modulations for Harmonica ad Orchestra

Alexander Tcherepnin and his Concerto for Harmonica and Orchestra ... the best piece of all listed!


Back to Top
Moshkiae1 View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 19 Jul 2025
Location: Grok City
Status: Offline
Points: 124
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Moshkiae1 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 13 Oct 2025 at 9:03am
Hi,

The Harmonica (and some of its variations)

One instrument, that is not always considered as valuable or important as another within the context of an orchestra. And the number of "composers" that know instruments, will normally leave this one behind, not realizing how special a moment can become.

And that relegates this instrument to the background, and in most cases, as you will see in the following articles, almost ignored, and not respected. And this leaves it all in the hands (and mouth) of the players that specialize in this instrument in many bars and popular hangouts where you might take your date out for a drink ... but you're not likely to find this on most places in America ... other than some locations that have a long history of BLUES, the area that this instrument is mostly associated with ... but there is another side of this that is rarely heard, and there are some magnificent things to listen to ... and they are not always right at the tip of your tongue for a whistle like so many hit songs on the radio, are.

I have compiled a listing, with some help from that wicked place, of a lot of things, and the internet ... with one horrible detail about it all, and the toob and googlio are the worst when it comes to database finding of things ... o you type "harmonica and orchestra" and it gives you a majority of violin and orchestra, as if the harmonica and violin were the same thing! 

It's impossible to do a proper search on the internet and there are no tools to help you improve those searches, and many other search engines make it look like they are better, and they use exactly the same tools, and it doesn't matter where you go. 

So, in the situations here, you type one person's name and you get 15 others with the "Harmonica Concerto" and your choice is not shown ... kinda makes you wonder how smart some of the folks that designed these things really are ... or the various bits added to make sure this or that is up front, is the real problem, meaning your search is not important.

I'm (at first) making sure some of these composers are not already listed in which case I will place their detail with their own thread, though I am not sure that will help things ... since that article may have been posted a long time ago, and not many replies have been added, which scares me, if it ends up placing this thread way out there in nowhere land and the notes and new information is lost ... another search issue for a database. It doesn't know if the material is new/different or not ... and worse, it doesn't care!

When I'm done re-checking to prevent things from getting doubled up, I will post the rest of the article right here, below.

BTW, a huge NOTE here ... this is not about SONGS! Or this is not such or such or such other. This is, for the most part, a bit on the classical side of things, and not exactly jazz oriented, though I find the freedom of movement that many players show, makes this instrument a very nice and important one for jazz purposes, but in all the works I found and have listed, sadly, I can not tell you that a single one of them is "jazz" in the conventional sense. It isn't exactly pop music either, though that is where the instrument is best known around blues players.

Here, it is ... all "classical", if you will allow me to state that, and I discuss it as music that is more valuable and important than just some style or other. 

(Will add after making sure I have no unnecessary duplication)


Edited by Moshkiae1 - 13 Oct 2025 at 9:21am
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply
  Share Topic   

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 10.16
Copyright ©2001-2013 Web Wiz Ltd.

This page was generated in 0.252 seconds.